Lumine Q2 2026 financial statements ↗
Pages 2–3 balance sheet and revenue; 7 cash flows; 11–12 Synchronoss; 16–17 debt; 19 shares; 22 working capital; 23 July transactions
Published Aug 4, 2026 · Reviewed Oct 31, 20268 of 11 research checks complete. Still to complete: Security and evidence base; Opportunities and funded scenarios; Variant view and catalysts · TTM September2026; September cash, gross bank principal and remaining acquisition claims; fixed October2026 exit vintage
Acquire mission-critical software, strengthen operations and redeploy after-financing cash. Recurring customer revenue supports the cash engine; acquisition price, integration and financing determine per-share compounding.
Recurring software cash reinvestment · TTM September2026; September cash, gross bank principal and remaining acquisition claims; fixed October2026 exit vintage
| Driver | Downside | Base | Upside |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dividend / available owner cash | 0.0% | 0.0% | 0.0% |
| Annual share dilution | 0.0% | 0.0% | 0.0% |
| Available cash deployment fraction | 50.0% | 100.0% | 100.0% |
| Organic revenue growth | Years 1–2: -4.0% Years 3–5: -1.0% | Year 1: 1.0% Years 2–5: 2.0% | Year 1: 2.0% Years 2–5: 3.0% |
| Owner-cash margin on organic revenue | Years 1–5: 25.5% | Year 1: 26.2% Year 2: 27.0% Years 3–5: 27.8% | Year 1: 27.5% Years 2–5: 29.0% |
| Price paid per unit of acquired revenue | Years 1–5: 2.00× | Year 1: 1.60× Years 2–5: 1.55× | Year 1: 1.60× Years 2–5: 1.55× |
| Owner-cash margin of acquired businesses | Years 1–3: 17.0% Years 4–5: 20.0% | Year 1: 22.0% Years 2–3: 26.0% Years 4–5: 30.0% | Year 1: 24.0% Years 2–3: 28.0% Years 4–5: 31.0% |
| Acquired revenue growth after purchase | Years 1–5: -2.0% | Years 1–5: 0.0% | Years 1–3: 0.0% Years 4–5: 1.0% |
| Deal budget (capital available for acquisitions) | Years 1–2: 23.00 Year 3: 105.57 Year 4: 108.61 Year 5: 111.36 | Years 1–2: 114.79 Year 3: 398.20 Year 4: 469.93 Year 5: 544.19 | Year 1: 673.13 Years 2–5: 730.07 |
| Exit / cash operating earnings | Year 1: 8.58× Year 2: 8.57× Year 3: 8.57× Year 4: 8.56× Year 5: 8.55× | Year 1: 19.97× Year 2: 19.67× Year 3: 18.86× Year 4: 18.05× Year 5: 17.28× | Year 1: 31.03× Year 2: 27.44× Year 3: 24.91× Year 4: 22.87× Year 5: 21.59× |
Lumine buys and operates software businesses serving communications and media customers. Money is USD millions unless stated. Source IDs refer to sources/registry.json; fact IDs to financials/facts.json; rec* and other step IDs to valuation/calculations.json.
What we are buying: subordinate voting shares of Lumine Group Inc. on the TSX Venture Exchange (LMN), 256.62m economic shares including one super-voting share held by Constellation Software (CSU) that carries 50.1% of votes and one share's economics (economicShares, lumine-q2-2026-fs). CSU also owns about 157.6m subordinate shares, a 61.4% economic interest (csuLumineShares, csi-q2-2024-mda). Lumine reports in USD; the shares trade in CAD. The fiscal year is the calendar year. The Q3 2026 report date is not confirmed in issuer sources (lumine-events).
| Question | Evidence used | What it cannot settle |
|---|---|---|
| Group economics, cash, capital | FY2022-FY2025 MD&As, FY2025 audited statements, Q2 2026 interim statements and MD&A | Business-unit P&Ls: Lumine reports one segment |
| Acquisition economics | Acquisition notes (FY2025 FS note 4, Q2 2026 FS notes 4 and 17), Motive announcement, Synchronoss 10-K and deal release | Post-close cash by deal; Motive's and WideOrbit's own revenue |
| Demand and cycle | Revenue by type and organic growth by quarter since 2021; customer and peer filings (Verizon, T-Mobile, Comcast, Nokia, Ericsson, Ribbon, Telenor) | Contract renewal rates, churn, price increases |
| Counterparties | Customer concentration notes, Synchronoss customer note, board page, CSU filings | The identity of Lumine's >10% customer; contract terms |
| Management | MD&A related-party and key-management notes, board page, CSU MD&A | The management information circular was not obtained; individual pay and holdings are unverified |
No fieldwork was done: no interviews with customers, former employees, sellers or competitors. Management statements are evidence of what management says.
Lumine buys established, mission-critical software that communications and media companies run their networks, devices, billing, advertising and broadcast operations on, usually when the seller no longer wants it: corporate carve-outs (Nokia's device management and service platform businesses as Motive, Arvato's Vidispine, Synamedia's video network assets in Quortex), founder exits (WideOrbit), or under-earning public companies (Synchronoss). It pays roughly 0.6-1.6x revenue, then "strengthens" the business: it removes overhead the business no longer needs inside a decentralized group, prices the installed base, and keeps funding maintenance and development so customers renew. The cash then funds the next purchase. Most value is created in the strengthening step, not the purchase multiple and not organic growth: group operating margin before amortization rose from 26.3% in FY2022 to 29.0%, 31.5% and 36.0% (FY2023-FY2025; opIncome2022-opIncome2025) while organic growth was −9%, 0%, −8% and +2% (organic2022-organic2025). Acquired revenue arrives at low margins and leaves at group margins. The measured FY2022-FY2025 achieved deal yield is about 20-26% after tax and before financing (stage 6), well above any plausible cost of capital, while organic growth contributes nearly nothing. The mechanism needs a supply of unloved assets at low prices; it does not need customers to buy more.
Comparable firms are chosen by these traits, not by the industry label.
Growth vehicle: Acquisitions. Revenue rose from 228.4 in FY2021 to 765.7 in FY2025, about 35% a year, while organic growth was −9%, 0%, −8% and +2% in FY2022–FY2025. Acquisition cash was 27.0% of revenue over FY2023–FY2025. Essentially all growth was bought, and value comes from strengthening the margins of acquired businesses, not from organic growth. The model buys revenue each year from a deal budget and grows the base at about zero.
Capital intensity: 0.4% of sales, asset-light. Capital spending is about 0.4% of revenue, and tangible capital including leases is about 5 because customers fund working capital. The capital that drives growth is acquisition cash (27% of revenue over FY2023–FY2025), spent mostly on carve-outs of communications and media software.
Comparables. A comparable firm buys software businesses, often carve-outs from larger vendors, serving a narrow customer set; earns mostly recurring maintenance revenue (70% in FY2025); raises margins after purchase; and needs almost no capital spending. Organic growth is near zero and growth is bought. Not the label: "Telecom software" ties Lumine to telecom capex cycles and organic SaaS peers; its value comes from buying and improving acquired businesses.
Declared in valuation/model.json (businessProfile). npm run check measures deal and capital intensity from the reported facts, and the outside view grades the forecast only against firms that share them.
FY2025, reported statements, definitions stated (fact IDs in brackets; normalization below).
| Measure | Value | Definition |
|---|---|---|
Revenue (revenue2025) | 765.7 | of which maintenance and other recurring 537.7 (70%) |
Operating income before amortization (opIncome2025) | 275.7 (36.0%) | issuer non-IFRS; expensed R&D 101.5 staff is inside |
| Delivery margin | about 75% | revenue less hardware 11.1, third-party 46.2, professional-services staff 59.5 and maintenance staff 75.5 |
| Incremental margin | 31.7% FY2023, 38.9% FY2024, 67.1% FY2025, 13.6% H1 2026 | change in operating income / change in revenue |
Unlevered owner cash before working capital (recEndCash) | 245.9 (32.1%) | operating cash after tax, lease cash and capex, before bank interest and interest income |
FCFA2S (fcfa2025) | 217.0 | issuer: after interest, leases and capex, before deals |
| Trade working capital | −9.5 | receivables 163.2 + unbilled 47.5 + inventory 0.6 − payables and accruals 123.8 − deferred revenue 97.0 |
| PP&E / right-of-use assets | 8.3 / 5.8 | |
| Tangible capital incl. leases | about 5 | trade working capital + PP&E + ROU |
| Return on tangible capital (leases capitalized), after tax | not meaningful | about 239 of after-tax operating income on about 5 of capital |
| Return on capital employed (leases expensed), after tax | not meaningful | negative trade working capital |
| Return incl. net acquired intangibles and goodwill | 32.6% after tax | (275.7 − 36.7 current tax) / (728.4 + 5) |
| Return incl. gross intangibles (before 414.1 accumulated amortization) | 20.8% after tax | / (1,142.5 + 5); book values partly carried at CSU's historical cost |
| Receivable days (incl. unbilled) | 78 (100) | on revenue |
| Deferred revenue | 46 days of revenue | maintenance billed in advance |
| Capex / depreciation | 0.49x; capex + lease cash / depreciation 1.1x | depreciation includes right-of-use assets |
| Net cash (debt), 31 Dec 2025 | +140.4 | cash 352.4 − bank debt 212.0; leases 6.8 |
| Net debt after July 2026 closings | about 275 | debt 485.0 − cash after July payments 210.4 |
Normalization before returns. Capex and lease cash together roughly equal depreciation, so no capex adjustment; there are no minorities. Recently acquired businesses are not in trailing earnings at full weight; the model adds them as funded cohorts (Synchronoss's missing months at the group cash margin; Quortex and Imagine at the purchase yield). Two items the model does not separately normalize: (1) the FY2024 working-capital outflow of 77.9 and the FY2025 outflow of 18.5 (the model treats ongoing working capital as zero; stage 6 treats the FY2024 build as part of the Motive purchase cost); (2) FY2025 current tax includes a 14.8 benefit from the US repeal of R&E capitalization, part of which is a one-time catch-up of previously capitalized costs (lumine-fy2025-mda p.10). The split is not disclosed; if half is non-recurring, normalized owner cash is overstated by about 7 (3%). This is recorded as an unquantified upward bias, not plugged.
The real capital in this business is the purchase price, not the balance sheet. Book intangibles understate it because Lumine Holdings came in at CSU's historical book value in a common-control transaction. Stage 6 therefore measures returns on matched acquisition capital.
Lumine reports one operating segment. Re-cut first by revenue type, because each type has different economics (FY2025; direct costs allocated by the staff department table, lumine-fy2025-mda pp.4-6; estimates):
| Stream | Revenue | Direct cost (est.) | Contribution (est.) | Share of contribution | Organic FY2025 / TTM Jun 2026 | Character |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Maintenance and other recurring | 537.7 | maintenance staff 75.5 + about 30 third-party | about 432 | about 75% | +2% / +3% | replacement-like; renews unless the customer migrates |
| Licences | 72.6 | small | about 72 | about 13% | −7% / +5% | lumpy upgrades and new sales; −36% in FY2024 |
| Professional services | 135.0 | PS staff 59.5 + about 16 third-party | about 60 | about 10% | +5% / −2% | implementation work tied to licence and upgrade cycles |
| Hardware and other | 20.3 | 11.1 | about 9 | about 2% | −1% / −21% | resale at 40-45% margin |
Contribution totals about 573; R&D 101.5, sales and marketing 49.0, G&A 67.4 and other opex about 80 bring it to 275.7. R&D and most sales and G&A exist to keep the recurring base renewing, so effectively all operating profit comes from maintenance and recurring revenue. Licence and service swings move reported growth but not the value.
Re-cut second by acquired cohort, because the cohorts have different demand drivers (FY2025 revenue estimated from the issuer's pro forma adjustments: 241.4 of FY2022 pre-acquisition revenue for the 2023 cohort, 228.2 of FY2023 for the 2024 cohort; fact-level detail in the MD&As):
| Cohort | Est. FY2025 revenue | Demand driver | Trend |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pre-2023 portfolio (Telarix interconnect, broadband and mobile operator software) | about 230-240 | operator network and billing operations | flat to slightly down; one 2022 deal lost customers who had given notice before purchase |
| 2023 cohort, mostly WideOrbit (TV and radio advertising sales and traffic software), WizTivi | about 240-270 | linear TV and radio advertising volumes and station counts | structural decline in linear advertising; licences fell sharply in FY2024 |
| 2024 cohort, Motive (device and service management from Nokia) and Axyom | about 200-240 | operators' device and home-gateway management | carries the single >10% customer (71.5 in nine months of 2024, 106.3 in FY2025) |
| 2025 deals (Vidispine, Datafusion) | about 31 | media asset management | small |
| Since the period: Synchronoss (Feb 2026), Quortex and Imagine (Jul 2026) | about 170 (Synchronoss annualized Q2) plus undisclosed | carrier-branded consumer cloud storage; broadcast playout and video delivery | Synchronoss top five customers 97.6% of its revenue |
Conclusion. The profit is in recurring maintenance on installed software, spread across cohorts whose end markets range from slowly declining (linear TV/radio advertising) to flat (operator back-office). No cohort is a growth engine. Concentration has risen: one undisclosed customer was 13.9% of FY2025 revenue, and Synchronoss adds Verizon and AT&T exposure. Counting Synchronoss at its annualized Q2 revenue, at least 40% of run-rate revenue (about 425 of about 950, before the July deals, whose revenue is undisclosed) now comes from businesses bought since April 2024.
The unit through which Lumine adds value is the acquired business. The comparison that matters is before and after Lumine's ownership. Three disclosed units:
| Synchronoss (Feb 2026) | Motive and Axyom (Apr 2024) | Datafusion (Jul 2025) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | 309.3 consideration; 277.5 all-in net of 34.3 cash plus 2.6 costs (synchronossNetAllInCost) | up to EUR185m incl. EUR35m contingent; FY2024 group deal cash 140.6 plus 77.9 working-capital build | 21.35 incl. 7.7 holdbacks and contingent |
| Revenue before purchase | 173.6 (FY2024, sncrRevenue2024) | about 195 (2023, from the issuer's pro forma adjustment, est.) | about 33 annualized (16.4 in the first six months) |
| Price / revenue | 1.6x | about 1.0-1.1x incl. working capital | 0.65x |
| Profit before purchase | income from operations 21.7 (12.5%); unlevered cash 28.5 (16.4%) = operating cash 28.3 + interest 15.1 − capex and capitalized software 14.9 | not disclosed (Nokia carve-out) | not disclosed |
| Entry yield (unlevered cash / all-in price) | 10.3% | n/a | n/a |
| After Lumine | at the group's 29.2% purchase cash margin (purchaseCashMargin) on 169 revenue: about 49, a 17.8% yield. Observed so far: net losses of 1.4 (Q2) and 3.9 (since close) after acquired-intangible amortization on 286 of intangibles | group unlevered cash rose 62.7 from FY2024 to FY2025 on 218.5 of FY2024 deal capital and working capital (recRoiic2025, 28.7%), mostly a full year of Motive | net income 1.7 in six months after amortization |
What the strengthening step changes, using Synchronoss. Synchronoss spent 29.8% of revenue on SG&A (51.7 on 173.6) and 24.7% on R&D (42.8) as a listed company. Lumine's whole group spends 6.4% on sales and marketing staff, 8.8% on G&A staff and 13.3% on R&D staff. Reaching the group margin needs about 21 of annual savings (12% of revenue), mostly listed-company and duplicated overhead (board, audit, listing, investor relations, separate management layers) and sales cost on a base whose top five customers are 97.6% of revenue and renew on three-to-five-year contracts. That is plausible but unproven; it is the single largest assumption in the funded cohorts.
A representative small deal, built from Datafusion and group ratios (illustrative): price 21 for 33 of revenue. At purchase it earns perhaps 10-15% unlevered cash margin (about 4); if Lumine lifts it to 25-30% over two to three years (about 9), the yield on price is 19% at entry-year cash and about 40% once strengthened, before working capital. Capital beyond the price is close to zero because maintenance is billed in advance, except in carve-outs that arrive without receivables.
Failure cases. (1) A 2022 acquisition was bought with "known material attrition from customer notifications" received before purchase, which produced −9% organic growth in FY2022 (lumine-fy2022-mda p.3): Lumine priced in a shrinking base, so this was a known decline rather than a mistake, but it shows the model's tolerance for declining assets. (2) After WideOrbit's first year, FY2024 organic growth was −8%, with licences −36% and hardware −46% (lumine-fy2024-mda p.5): the linear advertising customer base bought fewer upgrades. Maintenance held at +2%, which is the point of the model. (3) Synchronoss so far: reported losses after amortization, strengthening costs that lifted H1 2026 expenses to 70% of revenue against 66% a year earlier, and an incremental group margin of only 13.6% in H1 2026.
recYieldLow, recYieldHigh). The two are consistent once integration time and the FY2024 working-capital build are charged.aggAchievedYield) and above a 9-10% cost of equity. The conclusion that Lumine's purchases created value survives. Whether the rate is repeatable at 2026 prices is open: Synchronoss's entry yield was 10.3% and its price carried a 70% premium to the market (csi-synchronoss-release-2025), though entry yields of the record's deals were also below their achieved yields. The model prices future deals at the 19.9% low bound (3 November label reconciliation).Where the consensus may disagree. The 2025-2026 sell-off (from about C$55 in July 2025 to about C$19-26 in 2026, lumine-price-history-2026-11-03) is attributed in public commentary to AI disruption of vertical software and to slower deal flow. This study's reading is narrower: the risk to value is not that customers stop renewing (maintenance organic growth stayed +1% to +3%) but that the 2026 deals were bought at entry yields well below Lumine's record, with concentrated customers. The observation that would settle it is Synchronoss's post-close cash margin and maintenance organic growth in the Q3 and Q4 2026 reports.
Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-motive-announcement-2023, sncr-fy2024-10k, csi-synchronoss-release-2025, lumine-playbook.
Money is USD millions unless stated.
The listed company dates from February 2023: CSU transferred Lumine Holdings to the company at book value, the company bought WideOrbit for 504.6 (cash and debt repayment plus 10.2m special shares valued at 221.8), and CSU distributed the subordinate shares to its own shareholders (lumine-fy2023-mda pp.2-3). FY2021-FY2022 figures are the predecessor's combined carve-out accounts. In March 2024 the preferred and special shares converted into subordinate shares, and the accrued 5% dividends (about 87) were paid in shares. June 2026 statements show 256.620389m economic shares and no dilutive securities.
Trailing revenue is FY2025 plus H1 2026 less H1 2025: 846.4. The same bridge gives 185.4 of reported FCFA2S. Synchronoss (closed 13 February 2026) is in trailing results for part of a year; Quortex and Imagine (1 July) are not. Their purchase cash is deducted from the June cash balance, which already includes the debt drawn to prefund them. The latest financial results located are Q2, released 4 August 2026; Q3 accounts were not linked in issuer sources on 2 November (lumine-filings-public-table).
End user, payer and decision-maker. The end users are network engineers, operations staff, advertising sales and traffic teams at broadcasters, and consumers using carrier-branded apps (Synchronoss). The payer is the operator or broadcaster's IT or network budget. The decision-maker on renewal is usually an operations or IT executive for whom the system is already embedded; the decision-maker on replacement is a CTO-level programme that rarely touches a working back-office system unless a platform migration (5G core, IP/cloud playout, a merger) forces it.
Demand split, judged from revenue type (FY2025, lumine-fy2025-mda p.4):
| Part | Share of revenue | Driver | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Replacement-like (maintenance, support, hosted, subscriptions) | 70% (76% in H1 2026 with Synchronoss) | installed base continues to run the software | organic +2% FY2024, +2% FY2025, +3% TTM June 2026 (reported currency); no quarter below −1% since Q1 2023 (it fell as low as −11% in Q3 2022) |
| Upgrade and new-sale (licences, professional services) | 27% | operator and broadcaster project budgets; platform migrations | licences −36% FY2024, −7% FY2025; services −18% FY2024, +5% FY2025 |
| Resale (hardware) | 3% | project-attached | −46% FY2024 |
| Regulation-driven | small, not separable | lawful intercept, emergency messaging, broadcast compliance | no disclosure |
The cycle measured with data, not adjectives: total organic growth by year was −9% (FY2022, one deal's known attrition), 0% (FY2023), −8% (FY2024), +2% (FY2025) and +1% TTM June 2026 (organic2022-organicTtmJun2026). The swings are almost entirely licences, services and hardware; maintenance stayed between −1% and +8% by quarter. Customers' own budgets explain this split. Operators are cutting physical capex while service revenue grows slowly: T-Mobile reported lower capital spending in Q3 2026 (tmobile-q3-2026), Verizon and Comcast report flat-to-low connectivity growth (verizon-q3-2026, comcast-q3-2026), and Telenor's Nordic operations grow low single digits with disciplined capex (telenor-q3-2026-release). Network-vendor software segments (Nokia Core Software, nokia-q3-2026) are growing modestly. That environment squeezes project and licence spending but leaves running systems in place.
Market misperception, if any. The 2026 market narrative is that AI agents and cloud platforms will displace vertical software. The series that tests it for Lumine is maintenance and recurring organic growth: +1% FX-adjusted in Q2 2026 and +3% reported over the trailing year (lumine-q2-2026-mda p.6). It hasn't turned negative. A second, opposite misperception is possible: that Lumine is a growth company. It isn't; outside acquisitions, revenue has been flat for four years. The WideOrbit cohort faces a structural decline in linear TV and radio advertising, which no data here quantifies.
Competition happens product by product, at the operator or broadcaster account, not at the group level. Lumine's units compete with the large network and IT vendors (Nokia, Ericsson, Amdocs, Oracle, Netcracker) in operator software, with broadcast technology vendors (Grass Valley's AMPP and Altitude playout, grass-valley-ampp-2026) in channel origination, and with hyperscaler and in-house tools in cloud storage and video processing. Lumine has no meaningful market share at the industry level; each unit is a niche incumbent.
The advantage in one sentence: Lumine is often the buyer of last resort for products their original owners no longer want to fund, and it can earn a high return on them because the installed customers keep paying for support while Lumine cuts the cost of serving them. The evidence it is durable is the record of sellers (Nokia, Bertelsmann's Arvato, Synamedia, a public board) choosing Lumine, the measured 20-26% deal yield, and maintenance revenue that kept growing slightly while licence sales fell by a third.
Who could hurt the company. (1) Other permanent owners of vertical software competing for the same carve-outs: CSU's own operating groups, Topicus, private equity and other software consolidators; prices for listed targets (Synchronoss, a 70% premium) suggest more competition for larger deals. (2) Platform migrations: a customer moving to a new core network, a cloud broadcast platform or a merger partner's systems can end a renewal. Grass Valley's AMPP win at Channel 4 is an example of a competitor's platform replacing incumbent playout (no Lumine contract is identified). (3) The largest customers themselves, which can insource. Synchronoss's 10-K notes the cost and subscriber disruption Verizon or AT&T would face in replacing it (sncr-fy2024-10k), which is why they haven't, but that is the seller's own claim.
The number of competitors is not falling in Lumine's niches in any observable way; what changes is which products get abandoned by large vendors, which is Lumine's deal supply.
| Counterparty | What they want | What Lumine gives them | Outside options | What would change the arrangement |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CSU (61.4% economic, 50.1% votes via the super-voting share) | per-share compounding of the whole CSU family; capital placed at high returns without CSU management time | a dedicated communications-and-media acquirer, management fees of 3.0 a year (mgmtFees2025), an exit for deals outside other groups' verticals | CSU's Volaris and other groups can buy the same assets; CSU can sell or distribute shares | CSU needing cash, a change in CSU leadership philosophy (Mark Miller, CSU President and COO, chairs Lumine), or a conflict over which group gets a deal |
| Corporate sellers (Nokia, Arvato, Synamedia) | a clean exit from non-core products without stranding their own customers or brand | speed, certainty, a commitment to continuity (Lumine's 2023 Motive release stresses partnering with Nokia for a seamless transition) | shutdown (costly, angers customers), PE buyers | sellers learning to price carve-outs higher once Lumine's results are visible |
| Large customers (the undisclosed >10% customer; Verizon and AT&T through Synchronoss) | reliable systems at falling cost; leverage at renewal | continuity of embedded software, no migration risk | insource, migrate to a platform vendor, renegotiate | a platform migration, merger, or a renewal at lower price. Synchronoss's top five were 97.6% of its revenue; Lumine's single customer was 106.3 in FY2025 (13.9%) after 71.5 in nine months of FY2024, nil before Motive |
| WideOrbit's rollover holders (founder Eric Mathewson sits on the board) | value for shares received at a US$21.74 face value | about 10.1m special shares that converted at 3.43 subordinate shares each, about 35m shares (about 13.5%) at conversion (derived; later sales not tracked) | sell into a thin market | a large sale could press on the price; no evidence of one was located |
| Subsidiary lenders (WO Loan, Motive Loan, Synchronoss Loans, Lumine Facility) | covenant-compliant, ring-fenced cash flows | collateral of each subsidiary; no parent guarantee on the subsidiary loans | refuse refinancing | covenant stress at one subsidiary; maturities in 2028-2030 |
Dependence runs both ways. The large customer relationships are a risk to revenue but also the reason the assets are cheap and sticky: operators rarely rip out working device-management or storage platforms, and the seller (often the vendor that sold to them) wants Lumine to keep them served. The identity of the >10% customer is not disclosed; its appearance with the April 2024 Motive carve-out (and a 44.3 receivable at December 2024, lumine-fy2024-mda p.12) suggests it is tied to that business, either a major operator or Nokia as a reseller. This is an inference, not a disclosed fact, and it matters: a reseller has different renewal incentives from an end user.
CSU as controlling holder: it has never sold Lumine shares in the record located, holds a permanent-owner culture, and benefits from Lumine's per-share value roughly in proportion to its 61% stake, so its incentives largely match minority holders'. The agency risk is allocation of deals across CSU's groups, which outsiders cannot observe.
Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-mda, sncr-fy2024-10k, csi-q2-2024-mda, csi-synchronoss-release-2025, lumine-motive-announcement-2023, lumine-board-page, tmobile-q3-2026, verizon-q3-2026, comcast-q3-2026, telenor-q3-2026-release, nokia-q3-2026, grass-valley-ampp-2026.
Money is USD millions unless stated. The 2026 management information circular was not obtained in this pass, so individual pay, holdings and bonus terms are marked unverified. That is the main gap in this stage.
Who decides where the cash goes: David Nyland (CEO and director; previously CEO of NBS Technologies and Blueprint Software Systems; according to the issuer, he and his team built the portfolio since 2013), and a board chaired by Mark Miller, CSU's President and COO. CSU controls the vote through one super-voting share (50.1% of votes, one share's economics) and owns about 157.6m subordinate shares, 61.4% of the economics (csuLumineShares, csi-q2-2024-mda).
| Holder / director | Role | Economic interest | Purchases and sales | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Constellation Software | controlling holder | about 157.6m shares, 61.4% (C$4.1bn at C$26.15) | no sale located since the 2023 spin-out | csi-q2-2024-mda |
| WideOrbit rollover holders incl. Eric Mathewson (director, WideOrbit founder) | seller turned holder | about 35m shares at the March 2024 conversion (about 13.5%), derived from 10.1m special shares × 3.43; current holding unverified | not tracked | lumine-fy2023-mda p.22; lumine-board-page |
| David Nyland | CEO, director | a third-party aggregator reports about 0.07% (about 0.17m shares, about C$4m); unverified | unverified | aggregator only |
| Mark Miller, Brian Beattie, Laurie Schultz | CSU/Volaris executives and CSU director | personal holdings unverified | unverified | lumine-board-page |
| Lucie Laplante (audit chair), Paul Cowling | independent directors | unverified | unverified | lumine-board-release-2023 |
Pay. Key management personnel (executives and the board together) received 6.955 in FY2025 and 6.302 in FY2024, all salaries, bonus and benefits (keyMgmtComp2025, lumine-fy2025-mda p.14). There are no stock options, no share-based payment line and no dilution from compensation: shares outstanding were unchanged from the March 2024 conversion to June 2026. In the CSU family, executives' bonuses are tied to return on invested capital and growth, and a share of the after-tax bonus must buy shares in the market, held in escrow for years (CSU's own practice). Whether Lumine's plan copies it was not verified here.
What a stake is worth if the stock compounds. On the aggregator's figure, Nyland's stake at 12% a year would gain about C$3m over five years, smaller than five years of a CSU-family executive's cash pay. On that reading his interests are dominated by pay and by CSU's evaluation of him, not by his own shares. The dominant owner is CSU: a 12% compound on its C$4.1bn stake is about C$3.1bn over five years, against 3.0 a year of management fees. CSU's interest is per-share value.
Implied targets. No numerical hurdle rate is disclosed; the MD&A states the objective "to invest all of our FCFA2S in acquisitions which meet our hurdle rate" (lumine-fy2025-mda p.1). No incentive target can be backed out without the circular.
Record under this team, measured:
Independent references. None were collected: no former employees, sellers or customers were interviewed. Public evidence from counterparties is limited to the seller's continuity quote in the Motive release, two board observers drawn from operators (Proximus and Spring Fibre, lumine-board-release-2023) and Synchronoss's board accepting the offer. That is zero independent references, stated plainly.
Bench depth. Each acquired business keeps its own management (Motive, WideOrbit, Synchronoss and Imagine continue under their brands) and Lumine runs a decentralized model inherited from Volaris. The Volaris and CSU executives on the board are an outside bench. Key-person risk at Nyland exists but is reduced by CSU's ability to appoint.
Governing objective: invest all FCFA2S in acquisitions above a hurdle rate, with no dividend. The behaviour shows long-term value per share as the goal, with one caveat (principle 5).
Concrete evidence: the FCFA2S definition and the organic-growth definition are stated and reconciled every quarter; prior-period restatements were described as immaterial. No adjustment to bonus metrics was observable (no circular). Related-party transactions: management fees to the CSU parent (3.0 in FY2025, 2.8 in FY2024), reimbursement of parent expenses, and the 2023 common-control transfer of Lumine Holdings at book value with preferred shares to CSU. Board: seven directors, of whom four are CSU-affiliated (Miller, Beattie, Schultz, Nyland), one is a major selling holder (Mathewson) and two are independent (Laplante, Cowling, both from Canadian telecom and cable). Voting control (50.1%) sits with CSU regardless of economic ownership.
Agency costs (Mauboussin and Callahan pp.47-48):
Buybacks do not offset share compensation because neither exists. The valuation treats the agency cost by charging the management fee as an operating cost, applying no control premium, and pricing future deals at the low bound of Lumine's record rather than its midpoint, partly because deal allocation inside the family is unobservable.
Sources: lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, csi-q2-2024-mda, lumine-board-page, lumine-board-release-2023, lumine-motive-announcement-2023, csi-synchronoss-release-2025, lumine-price-history-2026-11-03.
Money is USD millions unless stated. Measurements are named steps in valuation/calculations.json (rec*, research audit steps not bound to the model).
From the statements (FY2021-FY2022 predecessor carve-out accounts, lumine-fy2022-mda p.9; FY2023 lumine-fy2023-mda p.13; FY2024-FY2025 lumine-fy2025-fs; H1 2026 lumine-q2-2026-fs).
| FY2021 | FY2022 | FY2023 | FY2024 | FY2025 | Five years | H1 2026 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Operating cash before working capital (after tax) | n/a | 61.5 | 120.7 | 192.8 | 254.9 | 111.7 | |
| Working capital | n/a | −26.9 | −12.5 | −77.9 | −18.5 | −23.4 | |
| Operating cash flow | 86.0 | 34.6 | 108.2 | 115.0 | 236.5 | 580.3 | 88.3 |
| Lease cash (principal and interest) | −3.0 | −5.9 | −6.6 | −5.0 | −4.1 | ||
| Capex net / depreciation incl. ROU | n/a | −0.8 / 5.3 | −1.1 / 7.9 | −2.9 / 9.1 | −4.0 / 8.1 | −1.8 / 4.4 | |
| Acquisitions, net of cash acquired | −13.5 | −114.6 | −317.0 | −140.6 | −16.8 | −602.5 | −277.1 |
| Non-cash consideration (special shares to WideOrbit holders) | (221.8) | (221.8) | |||||
| Dividends / buybacks | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 (preferred dividends of about 87 paid in shares) | 0 | 0 cash | 0 |
| Equity issued for cash (preferred to CSU, capital contributions) | 204.0 | 204.0 | |||||
| Net transfers with CSU (intercompany advances and repayments) | −79.6 | +104.9 | −33.1 | ||||
| Bank debt drawn less repaid | 0 | +19.7 | +135.0 | +127.7 | −70.7 | +211.7 | +273.2 |
| Bank interest and fees | −0.5 | −12.3 | −20.9 | −14.6 | −8.8 | ||
| Other (interest received, restricted cash, FX) | |||||||
| Net change in cash | −8.0 | +40.0 | +79.4 | +64.5 | +141.5 | +317.4 | +69.2 |
| Closing cash | 27.0 | 67.0 | 146.5 | 211.0 | 352.4 | 421.7 |
Rows reconcile to each year's reported net change once the "other" items (interest received, restricted cash, post-acquisition settlements and FX, each under 10 a year) are included; they are left blank rather than plugged. FY2021-FY2022 intercompany flows with CSU reflect the carve-out before the spin-out.
What the table shows about priorities. Over FY2022-FY2025 the business generated about 630 of operating cash before working capital and spent 589 net of cash acquired on acquisitions plus 222 of special shares; working capital absorbed 136, mostly in the Motive year. External money (CSU preferred and contributions 204, net bank debt 212) funded the gap, and cash built to 352 at the end of FY2025 before the 2026 deals. No cash was ever returned to shareholders. In H1 2026 Lumine drew 380 of new debt and repaid 107 to buy Synchronoss and prefund the July deals.
Window FY2022 to FY2025: revenue rose 510.0 (recSalesChange). Rates per dollar of sales change:
| Rate | Value | Step | Reading |
|---|---|---|---|
| Incremental M&A rate | 1.37 | recMnaRate (696.2 incl. the WideOrbit special shares / 510.0) | Lumine buys revenue at about 1.4x, consistent with deals at 0.6-1.6x revenue plus holdbacks |
| Internally generated intangibles (expensed R&D) | 0.12 | recRdRate (R&D staff +31.1 / revenue +266.0, FY2023-FY2025) | R&D grows with acquired teams; it is maintenance of products, not discretionary growth |
| Fixed capital rate | 0.00 | recFixedRate (capex and lease cash 25.5 vs depreciation 25.1) | no fixed capital intensity |
| Working capital rate | 0.21 investment | recWcRate (outflow 108.8 / 510.0) | unusual for software; almost all from FY2024, when the Motive carve-out arrived without receivables |
Inflection points. The working-capital rate turned from a source to a use in FY2024 (Motive carve-out; largest-customer receivable 44.3 from nil). The M&A rate collapsed in FY2025 (16.8 net), then jumped in 2026 (about 520 of cash in seven months). The same CEO was in charge throughout; CSU-appointed chairs oversaw both.
Owner earning power at the start and end of the window, measured as unlevered owner cash before working capital (operating cash after tax, lease cash and capex, before bank interest):
recStartCash), on the predecessor perimeter under CSU.recEndCash), a 32.1% margin.normalizedOwnerCash).Reinvestment rate. FY2023-FY2025 unlevered cash before working capital totalled about 543 (113.7, 183.3 and 245.9). Growth investment was 696 of acquisitions including non-cash consideration plus 109 of working capital, about 805: a 148% reinvestment rate, funded by CSU preferred cash, special shares and bank debt.
Incremental return, lagged. The cash change of 188.2 against matched capital of 823.0 (half of the FY2022 and FY2025 deal years, all of FY2023-FY2024 including the WideOrbit special shares and the FY2024 working-capital build) gives 22.9% (recIncrementalReturn). A one-year lagged rolling figure, FY2025 cash change 62.7 on FY2024 capital of 218.5, gives 28.7% (recRoiic2025), inflated by a full year of Motive and its cost reductions. A three-year rolling series isn't possible yet: the listed history is three years and one deal (WideOrbit) dominates it.
Operating leverage versus capital efficiency. The FY2025 incremental margin of 67% (ΔNOPAT ÷ Δsales at the operating line) was mostly operating leverage from cutting Motive's costs, a one-time gain per deal. Capital efficiency is the durable part: the business needs no fixed capital and, outside carve-outs, no working capital.
Growth identity. Growth in owner cash ≈ (investment ÷ starting earnings) × return on new capital: (823 ÷ 57.7) × 22.9% ≈ 3.3x, matching the observed rise from 57.7 to 245.9 (+3.3x of the base). It holds by construction because the inputs share definitions; the useful check is that the matched capital and cash definitions don't double count. The investment came from outside capital, so per share the result is smaller: FCFA2S per diluted share went from 0.15 (FY2022 pro forma) to 0.85 (FY2025), a 5.6x rise, helped by the low pre-spin base. The mix: organic investment is expensed (R&D) and contributed about nothing net (organic −6% cumulative); acquisitions earned 20-26%; payouts were zero.
| Date | Deal | Price | Revenue at purchase | Later results |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2022 | Several, incl. a business with known pre-purchase attrition; Telarix-related term loan October 2022 | 113.2 cash incl. holdbacks | undisclosed | organic −9% in FY2022 from the attrition, as expected at purchase |
| Feb 2023 | WideOrbit (TV and radio advertising software) | 504.6: about 282.8 cash and debt repayment plus 221.8 of special shares | the 2023 cohort had 241.4 of FY2022 revenue (pro forma; mostly WideOrbit) | group margin 29.0% in FY2023; licences −36% in FY2024 |
| Nov 2023 | WizTivi | undisclosed; €10m loan | undisclosed | loan repaid by 2026 |
| Apr 2024 | Motive (Nokia device management and service management platform) and Axyom Core | up to €185m incl. €35m contingent; FY2024 deal cash 140.6 plus 77.9 working-capital build | 2024 cohort had about 195 of FY2023 revenue (est. from the 228.2 pro forma adjustment) | FY2025 group unlevered cash +62.7 |
| Apr 2025 | Vidispine (from Arvato/Bertelsmann) | 9.0 incl. holdbacks; bargain-purchase gain 2.2 | 14.9 contributed in nine months | net income 1.0 in nine months after amortization |
| Jul 2025 | Datafusion | 21.35 incl. 7.7 holdbacks and contingent | 16.4 contributed in six months | net income 1.7 in six months |
| Feb 2026 | Synchronoss | 309.3; 277.5 all-in net of cash | 173.6 (FY2024); 42.3 in Q2 2026 | net losses 3.9 since close after amortization; cash margin unobserved |
| Jul 2026 | Quortex (Synamedia video network assets) | 94.652 updated total consideration | Q3 21.511 | Q3 net income 1.120 includes 4.904 bargain gain |
| Jul 2026 | Imagine Communications | 136.832 updated total consideration | Q3 35.611 | Q3 net loss 6.826; cash margin unobserved |
Aggregate. FY2022-FY2025 matched capital of 823.0 bought businesses that, with their strengthening, added 163.8-191.8 of unlevered owner cash by FY2025 (recAcquiredCashLow, recAcquiredCashHigh). The achieved deal yield is 19.9% (low) to 25.7% (high); 23.3% midpoint including carve-out working capital (recYieldLow, recYieldMid, recYieldHigh). Bounds, as stage 6 requires: the high bound credits all margin gains to deals and charges the reported −6% cumulative organic decline to the legacy base; the low bound gives the legacy base the FY2025 margin (32.1%) and no decline. The base business's start-year margin was 22.6%. Organic growth from FY2024 includes WideOrbit after its first year, which moves some of WideOrbit's decline into the "legacy" base and flatters the high bound; the low bound removes that.
Comparison and deployment pace. CSU's measured group yield over 2020-2025 is 15.1% (aggAchievedYield), the model's base purchase price until the 3 November label reconciliation and now its downside anchor. Lumine's own record is higher, but it rests on two large carve-out and founder deals bought between February 2023 and April 2024, and the 2026 deals were priced differently: Synchronoss's entry yield was 10.3% and its offer a 70% premium to market. Deployment was lumpy: 539 in FY2023 including shares, 141 in FY2024, 17 in FY2025, about 520 in seven months of 2026. The old January2024–July2026 average of about 265 a year is a diagnostic. Current budgets instead use matched internal funding ratios, with explicit first-two-year limits and a fixed upside supply ceiling; see the September update below.
Conclusion for current deal economics. The historical low-bound 19.9% supports a limit to test, not a single copied yield. The revenue forecast pays 1.6×/1.55× sales, with acquired cash margins improving over time; mature base yield is 19.35%. Downside matures at 10% and upside at 20%. Group strengthening and the limited deal record constrain these judgments. Historical calibration and frozen checks stay in their original records; current annual paths and capital sums are in the model and research/10-capital-efficiency.md.
Then research/10-capital-efficiency.md contains the shared-engine forward diagnostics.
Source: Q3 statements pp.2, 7, 12–15, 18–20, 23–24; MD&A p.11, published 4 November. Nine-month CFO 155.173, financing 189.333, investing −491.507 and FX −3.040 reconcile opening cash 352.441 to closing 202.400. Acquisition cash was 527.751, acquired cash 43.480 and older settlement payments 5.699. Q3 bank repayments were 59.375, leaving gross principal 425.625. The model uses gross principal, rather than 422.526 book debt net of deferred fees.
Remaining holdbacks 12.268 plus separate contingent consideration 2.313 replace earlier June/July claims. July acquisition cash is already in September cash. Actual target revenue now shortens the missing-month bridge; Quortex's 4.904 bargain-purchase gain is not recurring operating cash, and Imagine's Q3 loss does not establish a group cash margin.
Matched internally funded deployment over January2022–September2026 is 0.6845 of reported matching FCFA2S (internalDeployRatioSep26), compared with 0.6318 in the old July window. Historical all-in and internal ratios are kept separately. The base carries the two existing repayment-period budgets, then uses the updated ratio to state annual dollar budgets. Deal supply and actual available cash still constrain deployment; a new accounting window is not a larger seller opportunity set.
Nine-month current tax 45.808 less cash paid 36.913 leaves an 8.895 timing diagnostic. It is not automatically a permanent tax benefit. Product development (R&D staff 115.2) remains charged; no unsupported growth-intangible capitalization is added. The model assumes refinancing of the remaining principal and does not model a default or new leverage. Principal due in 2028–2030 remains material.
Current forecast, funding and return attribution.
Assessment:5 November 2026. Communications and media software is costly for customers to replace, but recurring revenue still faces customer bargaining and technology substitution. Lumine buys businesses, strengthens them and reinvests owner cash. Acquisition-led revenue growth, recurring organic growth and target margin recovery are different mechanisms. The Q3 report improves the starting cash/debt bridge without proving future target supply or mature acquired cash margins.
No original investor forecast is invented. The live terminal valuation is independently reconstructed from finite future owner cash and capital costs. Sources support its operating anchors, not the chosen required returns or advantage durations.
Quote CAD 26.36, market time 2026-11-04T20:59:59.000Z; valuation date 5 November 2026. Fixed original exits:26 October 2031/2036. Current reported anchors, normalized earning power and forward estimates remain separate.
| Horizon | Bear | Base | Bull | Weighted cash-flow IRR |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 years | -3.18% | 18.40% | 32.91% | 17.57% |
| 10 years | 1.68% | 14.42% | 20.61% | 13.60% |
The reported September bridge and existing staged organic/target margins remain. Every scenario now shares the fixed CAD730.073m annual seller-supply ceiling; cash does not establish more sellers. Retained cash remains separate and earns the specified capped debt-saving/deposit return. Subsequent annual target purchases are funded without new borrowing. The base’s later budgets stop at the same seller limit as upside.
The main failure is mistaking a plausible mechanism for an evidenced quantity. Integration costs and customer attrition could persist, reported cash could include timing benefits, debt may refinance at worse terms and acquisition supply could be insufficient at the stated prices. A controlling shareholder and subsidiary restrictions can separate consolidated cash from cash accessible to common holders. The adverse scenario represents a specific failure path, not a maximum loss or a frequency estimate. The independent advocates’ strongest surviving attacks are recorded in 12-debate.md.
Each forecast year has its own terminal owner-cash multiple. The adverse/base/favorable tails run 5/10/15 additional years at 11%/9.5%/8.5% required owner returns. They continue the scenario’s operating margins and modest organic/acquired growth, charge each purchase once, cap annual purchase capital by seller supply and owner cash, then assume no further growth or acquisitions. Current retained cash is valued separately once; no second bank-debt deduction is made from after-financing equity cash. Base multiples are 17.277× at the five-year exit and 14.250× at the ten-year exit: a fixed dollar opportunity is worth less per earnings dollar as the portfolio grows. Duration and discount rates are low-confidence judgments. The annual revenue/cash/capital ledger and 0/5/10/15-year duration sensitivities are inspectable in the model-change record; local sensitivities hold this researched tail fixed.
Customer attrition, lower target cash margins, expensive purchases and a short profitable opportunity period jointly reduce owner value. The current low-growth/low-margin path and five-year finite tail express this mechanism. Tax timing is not made into a permanent benefit, no new facility is inferred from covenant compliance, and uncapped earnouts/access to subsidiary cash remain unresolved. Zero common recovery and financing failure can still occur outside the representative paths.
The potential opportunity is buying a recurring software cash base plus disciplined acquisitions at an attractive price. Q3’s stronger cash bridge helps, but the apparent discount depends on target integration, accessible funding and sustained attractive purchases. The debate rejects an unlimited central deal supply and a peer-table terminal shortcut. A18.40% five-year base remains conditional; the longer-horizon base falls to 14.42% as finite seller supply limits compounding relative to a larger portfolio. Neither total revenue growth nor an external investor’s return table establishes that mispricing.
The following liquidity/holder observations retain their original 3 November measurement window; they are context, not a new float or short-interest survey.
Evidence, not adjectives:
Neglect or justified discount? Partly neglect (venture exchange, thin float, a controlled company), partly justified (modest organic growth, demanding integration, concentration). The illiquidity is real: an outside investor cannot build or exit a large position quickly.
| Observation | Where and when | Refutes |
|---|---|---|
| Maintenance and recurring organic growth below −2% for two quarters | Q3 and Q4 2026 MD&A organic tables (Q3 published 4 November; next report date unconfirmed) | the intact recurring base; moves weight to the downside |
| Synchronoss cash margin: group operating margin back above 33% by H1 2027, or still near 30% | FY2026 and H1 2027 MD&A operating income and FCFA2S | the funded-cohort convergence estimate |
| The >10% customer's revenue | FY2026 MD&A customer concentration note | the stability of the Motive cohort |
| Deal pace and pricing: acquisitions over the next 12 months below 150 or entry prices above 1.5x revenue | quarterly acquisition notes | the ratio-based deal budget and staged purchased margins |
| A special dividend or buyback | issuer releases | the model's retain-and-repay assumption (Lumine's FY2025 behaviour); a dividend would not lower value but would end the interest saving |
| CSU sells or proposes to buy out minorities | CSU and Lumine filings | the controlling-holder alignment |
The deal-pace and owner-cash checks are frozen in valuation/prospective-checks.json (3 November, both model vintages; the calendar-2028 owner-cash check tests the deal-yield choice); the organic-growth, Synchronoss-margin and customer observations are review triggers here and in research/11-scenario-probabilities.md, not frozen predictions, because the model makes no numerical forecast of them. Permanent-loss paths and unverified inputs are in research/06-risks.md.
The independent debate links each surviving attack to the relevant reporting event. Earlier frozen predictions remain unchanged; new debate-vintage forecasts below are stored separately rather than backfitted to realized outcomes. Same-price/date returns, sensitivities and claim judgments; annual model-change arithmetic.
Assessment: 5 November 2026. The independent debate sizes the risks below against current scenarios. These are business and financing mechanisms, not forecasts of exact failures or a worst-case loss bound.
Apply the same 730.073 CADm annual seller limit to every scenario; cash is funding, not target supply. No25%arbitrary haircut or new borrowing. Capped later purchases leave unplaced cash visible. Evidence: lumine-fy2022-mda through lumine-fy2025-mda; lumine-q3-2026-fs pp.12–15; named supplyCeilingCad/internalDeployRatioSep26.
Replace live peer binding with yearly terminal multiple paths. Central5/10-year multiples are 17.277x/14.250x under the fixed-dollar tail. Preserve peer arithmetic as comparison and source calibration; bridge/sensitivity/model sheet read actual dated multiples. Evidence: named peerExitMultiple (preserved reference); updates/2026-11-05-debate-model-change.json finite annual revenue/cash/capital ledger.
No additional normalization, immediate target cash or arbitrary margin cut. Keep current staged recovery and explicit customer/refinancing/earnout/tax risks. Those survive the debate, constrain conviction and are already represented in adverse paths; they require future evidence. Evidence: lumine-q3-2026-fs pp.7,12–15,18–25; lumine-q3-2026-mda pp.9–17.
Moderate in the recurring-software acquisition mechanism, low in precise target margins, accessible funding and postexit duration. Q3 accounts strengthen the starting bridge but do not prove future target supply or ten-year returns.
Reassess after coherent capped scenarios and independent terminal definitions; retain existing coarse horizon-specific weights because stronger Q3 cash and persistent integration/customer/refinancing risks do not establish revised numerical frequencies. No odds fitted to returns.
Next reported quarter and FY2026 accounts (date not confirmed): acquired cash margins, organic recurring sales, cash taxes/debt, target deal prices and accessible liquidity; 24November technology conference is not an earnings report.
Full bull case, bear case and rebuttals; same-price/date financial effects. Existing frozen predictions are preserved, with the new debate vintage dated separately.
Current assessment:5 November 2026. The source calibration is preserved separately. Reported facts, normalization estimates and new forecast judgments keep their own evidence labels.
| Model input | Value | Classification | Economic definition and evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| equityCashEarnings | 341.902 | normalized estimate | September trailing reported FCFA2S, signed working-capital normalization, 6% on current gross principal, identified transaction expenses and cash interest removed. Cash taxes, leases, sustaining capex and development stay charged. Current-tax timing is disclosed separately; target profit recovery is not reported cash. Sources: lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs, lumine-fy2025-mda, boc-usdcad-2026-10-26, lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| shares | 256.620 | reported | 256.620389m shares = 256.620388m subordinate voting shares plus the single super-voting share, which has the same economic rights. June 2026 note 10. Preferred/special securities converted in March 2024; no extra outstanding preferred claim is deducted. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| openingCash | 283.866 | pro forma estimate | Use reported September cash 202.400. July acquisitions, acquired cash and Q3 debt repayments are already included. Restricted cash is separately classified in other assets; do not add it or redraw facilities. Remaining acquisition claims are charged separately. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs |
| revenue | 1331.879 | reported trailing revenue | FY2025 +9M2026−9M2025 reported consolidated revenue, translated consistently. Funded missing annual sales are additional named revenue contributions; no already consolidated quarter is added twice. Sources: lumine-fy2025-fs, lumine-q2-2026-fs, boc-usdcad-2026-10-26, lumine-q3-2026-fs |
The reported September bridge and existing staged organic/target margins remain. Every scenario now shares the fixed CAD730.073m annual seller-supply ceiling; cash does not establish more sellers. Retained cash remains separate and earns the specified capped debt-saving/deposit return. Subsequent annual target purchases are funded without new borrowing. The base’s later budgets stop at the same seller limit as upside.
Each forecast year has its own terminal owner-cash multiple. The adverse/base/favorable tails run 5/10/15 additional years at 11%/9.5%/8.5% required owner returns. They continue the scenario’s operating margins and modest organic/acquired growth, charge each purchase once, cap annual purchase capital by seller supply and owner cash, then assume no further growth or acquisitions. Current retained cash is valued separately once; no second bank-debt deduction is made from after-financing equity cash. Base multiples are 17.277× at the five-year exit and 14.250× at the ten-year exit: a fixed dollar opportunity is worth less per earnings dollar as the portfolio grows. Duration and discount rates are low-confidence judgments. The annual revenue/cash/capital ledger and 0/5/10/15-year duration sensitivities are inspectable in the model-change record; local sensitivities hold this researched tail fixed.
Revenue build (3 November). Organic revenue grows 1% in year 1, 2% in years 2-5 and 1.5% after. Its owner-cash margin recovers from 26.6% to 27.8% as 2026 strengthening costs roll off. New deals buy revenue at 1.6x (2026 pricing) and then at the 1.55x record, and converge from 22% to the 30% group margin by year 4. The deal budget is 81.9 a year in years 1-2 (debt-repayment years) and then the 131.7 FY2021-FY2025 average (USD; inputs.yearly.deploymentCapacity); unplaced cash repays debt, then earns a deposit rate. Exit at 17.7x (Topicus trailing, converted). Purchase economics are financing-neutral; owner cash retains the legacy debt cost. Terminal value uses finite postexit cash and capped annual purchases, with the researched year-specific multiple path; peer multiples are reference evidence only.
| Driver | Value/path | Reason and sources |
|---|---|---|
| payoutRatio | 0.000 | Zero reflects no declared dividend and management’s stated goal to reinvest FCFA2S. Operating FCF is not a shareholder receipt. Apply observed 1% organic growth to after-investment baseline cash, fund new deals with cash already on hand and future owner cash, and assume no additional borrowing. Sources: lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda |
| dilutionRate | 0.000 | Zero additional dilution: issued shares were unchanged in FY2025 and H1 2026; no preferred conversion is still outstanding. Future issuance or compensation policy can change this assumption. Apply observed 1% organic growth to after-investment baseline cash, fund new deals with cash already on hand and future owner cash, and assume no additional borrowing. Sources: lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda |
| reinvestmentRate | 1.000 | Base/upside 100% follows the stated FCFA2S reinvestment objective. The 50% stress retains cash for liquidity; retained cash adds to terminal equity once. Apply observed 1% organic growth to after-investment baseline cash, fund new deals with cash already on hand and future owner cash, and assume no additional borrowing. Sources: lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda |
| organicGrowth, years 1–1 | 0.010 | TTM June 2026 organic growth was +1% reported (0% FX-adjusted). Maintenance and recurring revenue grew +1% FX-adjusted in Q2 2026, while professional services fell 13% and licences 1%. Synchronoss is not yet in the organic base, and the >10% customer (USD106.3m in FY2025) shows no decline. Year 1 repeats the latest observed rate. Sources: lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| organicGrowth, years 2–5 | 0.020 | FY2025 organic growth was +2% reported. Maintenance and recurring (76% of H1 2026 revenue) grew +2-3% reported in FY2024, FY2025 and TTM June 2026, and licence and services volumes have no further trend once the FY2024 slump (licences −36%) is in the base. From February 2027 Synchronoss joins the organic base: its standalone revenue grew 5.7% in FY2024 on cloud subscriber growth, against WideOrbit's linear-advertising decline. 0.76 × 2.5% plus flat project revenue gives about 2%. Sources: lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs, lumine-fy2024-mda, sncr-fy2024-10k, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| organicGrowth, years 6–10 | 0.015 | Fades by half a point. Linear TV and radio advertising (the WideOrbit cohort, about a third of FY2025 revenue) keeps shrinking, and platform migrations (cloud playout, new core networks) replace some products at renewal. Lumine's record has had no year above +2% since 2021. Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| organicMargin, years 1–1 | 0.262 | September normalized trailing cash margin is about 25.7%; recover about half a point in the first year while the newly acquired lower-margin businesses are strengthening. No immediate return to the former 27% assumption. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda |
| organicMargin, years 2–2 | 0.270 | Staged integration and removal of identified transaction friction; retain operating/product costs. A forecast judgment, not issuer guidance or an achieved target cash margin. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda |
| organicMargin, years 3–10 | 0.278 | Retain the prior long-run base normalization below the historical financing-neutral margin after debt cost; do not extrapolate quarterly recovery indefinitely. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda |
| priceToSales, years 1–1 | 1.600 | The 2026 deals were priced like Synchronoss: 277.5 all-in for 173.6 of revenue, 1.60x (sncrPriceToSales), a public take-private at a 70% premium. The July deals' revenue is undisclosed. Sources: lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, sncr-fy2024-10k, csi-synchronoss-release-2025 |
| priceToSales, years 2–10 | 1.550 | Lumine's FY2022-FY2025 record: 823.0 of matched capital, including the Motive working-capital build, bought 525.7 of FY2025 revenue, 1.57x (recPriceToSales). By deal: WideOrbit 2.09x on its cohort's prior-year revenue, Motive about 1.0-1.1x including working capital, Datafusion 0.65x, Vidispine about 0.45x, Synchronoss 1.60x. Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs, lumine-motive-announcement-2023 |
| acquiredMargin, years 1–1 | 0.220 | Deals in their first contributing year earn below group margin. Synchronoss earned a 16.4% unlevered cash margin standalone (sncrStandaloneMargin) and was still loss-making after amortization in H1 2026. Strengthening costs lifted H1 2026 expenses to 70% of revenue. Applies to all acquired cohorts in that calendar year. Sources: lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, sncr-fy2024-10k, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| acquiredMargin, years 2–3 | 0.260 | Partway to group margin. Group unlevered cash rose 62.7 in the first full year after Motive (recRoiic2025), and operating margin stepped from 31.5% to 36.0% in FY2025, so most of the strengthening comes in the second and third year. Sources: lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| acquiredMargin, years 4–10 | 0.300 | Acquired businesses reach about the group's financing-neutral margin: FY2022-FY2025 deals earned 31.2% of their revenue by FY2025 even at the low bound (recAcquiredMarginLow), against the 29.2-31.7% group range. With a 1.55x price this is a 19.4% yield, in line with Lumine's 19.9% low-bound record yield (lumineRecordMultiple). Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| acquiredGrowth, years 1–10 | 0.000 | Acquired revenue held flat. Lumine's reported organic growth, which includes acquired businesses after their first year, averaged −1.25% a year over FY2023-TTM June 2026 (0%, −8%, +2%, +1%), weighed down by WideOrbit. The record deal yield already embeds early post-deal trends. Sources: lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs |
| deploymentCapacity, years 1–2 | 114.795 | Debt repayment competes for cash. H1 2026 drew 380 of bank debt for Synchronoss and the July deals, which are already funded cohorts and not counted again. After its earlier debt-funded deals Lumine deployed 140.6 (FY2024) and 23.1 (FY2025, while repaying 125.7), an average of USD81.9m (deployAfterDebtAvg). 5 November debate: the same fixed seller-supply ceiling applies in every scenario; excess cash remains retained. Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda |
| deploymentCapacity, years 3–3 | 398.195 | 4 November Q3 update: 0.6845 × model year-3 owner cash (581.712 CAD m). Stated budget 398.195 CAD m, solved from the shared forecast without using an IRR target. The ratio is internally funded purchases on a matched January2022–September2026 cash/financing window. Actual purchases also remain limited by cash after claims. 5 November debate: the same fixed seller-supply ceiling applies in every scenario; excess cash remains retained. Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| deploymentCapacity, years 4–4 | 469.931 | 4 November Q3 update: 0.6845 × model year-4 owner cash (686.510 CAD m). Stated budget 469.931 CAD m, solved from the shared forecast without using an IRR target. The ratio is internally funded purchases on a matched January2022–September2026 cash/financing window. Actual purchases also remain limited by cash after claims. 5 November debate: the same fixed seller-supply ceiling applies in every scenario; excess cash remains retained. Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| deploymentCapacity, years 5–5 | 544.187 | 4 November Q3 update: 0.6845 × model year-5 owner cash (794.988 CAD m). Stated budget 544.187 CAD m, solved from the shared forecast without using an IRR target. The ratio is internally funded purchases on a matched January2022–September2026 cash/financing window. Actual purchases also remain limited by cash after claims. 5 November debate: the same fixed seller-supply ceiling applies in every scenario; excess cash remains retained. Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| deploymentCapacity, years 6–6 | 627.889 | 4 November Q3 update: 0.6845 × model year-6 owner cash (917.266 CAD m). Stated budget 627.889 CAD m, solved from the shared forecast without using an IRR target. The ratio is internally funded purchases on a matched January2022–September2026 cash/financing window. Actual purchases also remain limited by cash after claims. 5 November debate: the same fixed seller-supply ceiling applies in every scenario; excess cash remains retained. Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| deploymentCapacity, years 7–7 | 723.847 | 4 November Q3 update: 0.6845 × model year-7 owner cash (1057.449 CAD m). Stated budget 723.847 CAD m, solved from the shared forecast without using an IRR target. The ratio is internally funded purchases on a matched January2022–September2026 cash/financing window. Actual purchases also remain limited by cash after claims. 5 November debate: the same fixed seller-supply ceiling applies in every scenario; excess cash remains retained. Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| deploymentCapacity, years 8–8 | 730.073 | 4 November Q3 update: 0.6845 × model year-8 owner cash (1218.147 CAD m). Stated budget 833.848 CAD m, solved from the shared forecast without using an IRR target. The ratio is internally funded purchases on a matched January2022–September2026 cash/financing window. Actual purchases also remain limited by cash after claims. 5 November debate: the same fixed seller-supply ceiling applies in every scenario; excess cash remains retained. Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| deploymentCapacity, years 9–9 | 730.073 | 4 November Q3 update: 0.6845 × model year-9 owner cash (1402.347 CAD m). Stated budget 959.938 CAD m, solved from the shared forecast without using an IRR target. The ratio is internally funded purchases on a matched January2022–September2026 cash/financing window. Actual purchases also remain limited by cash after claims. 5 November debate: the same fixed seller-supply ceiling applies in every scenario; excess cash remains retained. Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| deploymentCapacity, years 10–10 | 730.073 | 4 November Q3 update: 0.6845 × model year-10 owner cash (1613.475 CAD m). Stated budget 1104.460 CAD m, solved from the shared forecast without using an IRR target. The ratio is internally funded purchases on a matched January2022–September2026 cash/financing window. Actual purchases also remain limited by cash after claims. 5 November debate: the same fixed seller-supply ceiling applies in every scenario; excess cash remains retained. Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| exitMultiple, years 1–1 | 20.036 | Finite10-year postexit acquisition/organic opportunity at 9.5%required return; fixed seller ceiling and explicit capital costs. Scale changes the multiple by year. The duration and required return are subjective judgments. Full annual ledger is in the 5 November debate model-change record. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
| exitMultiple, years 2–2 | 19.701 | Finite10-year postexit acquisition/organic opportunity at 9.5%required return; fixed seller ceiling and explicit capital costs. Scale changes the multiple by year. The duration and required return are subjective judgments. Full annual ledger is in the 5 November debate model-change record. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
| exitMultiple, years 3–3 | 18.859 | Finite10-year postexit acquisition/organic opportunity at 9.5%required return; fixed seller ceiling and explicit capital costs. Scale changes the multiple by year. The duration and required return are subjective judgments. Full annual ledger is in the 5 November debate model-change record. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
| exitMultiple, years 4–4 | 18.048 | Finite10-year postexit acquisition/organic opportunity at 9.5%required return; fixed seller ceiling and explicit capital costs. Scale changes the multiple by year. The duration and required return are subjective judgments. Full annual ledger is in the 5 November debate model-change record. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
| exitMultiple, years 5–5 | 17.277 | Finite10-year postexit acquisition/organic opportunity at 9.5%required return; fixed seller ceiling and explicit capital costs. Scale changes the multiple by year. The duration and required return are subjective judgments. Full annual ledger is in the 5 November debate model-change record. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
| exitMultiple, years 6–6 | 16.512 | Finite10-year postexit acquisition/organic opportunity at 9.5%required return; fixed seller ceiling and explicit capital costs. Scale changes the multiple by year. The duration and required return are subjective judgments. Full annual ledger is in the 5 November debate model-change record. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
| exitMultiple, years 7–7 | 15.747 | Finite10-year postexit acquisition/organic opportunity at 9.5%required return; fixed seller ceiling and explicit capital costs. Scale changes the multiple by year. The duration and required return are subjective judgments. Full annual ledger is in the 5 November debate model-change record. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
| exitMultiple, years 8–8 | 15.129 | Finite10-year postexit acquisition/organic opportunity at 9.5%required return; fixed seller ceiling and explicit capital costs. Scale changes the multiple by year. The duration and required return are subjective judgments. Full annual ledger is in the 5 November debate model-change record. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
| exitMultiple, years 9–9 | 14.643 | Finite10-year postexit acquisition/organic opportunity at 9.5%required return; fixed seller ceiling and explicit capital costs. Scale changes the multiple by year. The duration and required return are subjective judgments. Full annual ledger is in the 5 November debate model-change record. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
| exitMultiple, years 10–10 | 14.250 | Finite10-year postexit acquisition/organic opportunity at 9.5%required return; fixed seller ceiling and explicit capital costs. Scale changes the multiple by year. The duration and required return are subjective judgments. Full annual ledger is in the 5 November debate model-change record. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
An explicit stress, not issuer guidance: 2% annual baseline cash erosion, 50% deployment to preserve liquidity, purchases costing 75% more per unit of cash earnings and a 35% lower terminal multiple. This tests weaker retention, integration and financing sentiment; it is not a financing-default simulation. Purchase economics are financing-neutral with respect to legacy group debt; owner cash retains that debt cost. Terminal value uses finite postexit cash and capped annual purchases, with the researched year-specific multiple path; peer multiples are reference evidence only.
| Driver | Value/path | Reason and sources |
|---|---|---|
| payoutRatio | 0.000 | Zero reflects no declared dividend and management’s stated goal to reinvest FCFA2S. Operating FCF is not a shareholder receipt. An explicit stress, not issuer guidance: 2% annual baseline cash erosion, 50% deployment to preserve liquidity, purchases costing 75% more per unit of cash earnings and a 35% lower terminal multiple. This tests weaker retention, integration and financing sentiment; it is not a financing-default simulation. Sources: lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda |
| dilutionRate | 0.000 | Zero additional dilution: issued shares were unchanged in FY2025 and H1 2026; no preferred conversion is still outstanding. Future issuance or compensation policy can change this assumption. An explicit stress, not issuer guidance: 2% annual baseline cash erosion, 50% deployment to preserve liquidity, purchases costing 75% more per unit of cash earnings and a 35% lower terminal multiple. This tests weaker retention, integration and financing sentiment; it is not a financing-default simulation. Sources: lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda |
| reinvestmentRate | 0.500 | Base/upside 100% follows the stated FCFA2S reinvestment objective. The 50% stress retains cash for liquidity; retained cash adds to terminal equity once. An explicit stress, not issuer guidance: 2% annual baseline cash erosion, 50% deployment to preserve liquidity, purchases costing 75% more per unit of cash earnings and a 35% lower terminal multiple. This tests weaker retention, integration and financing sentiment; it is not a financing-default simulation. Sources: lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda |
| organicGrowth, years 1–2 | -0.040 | Repeats half of FY2024's −8% organic decline, when licences fell 36%, services 18% and hardware 46%. It adds a partial loss or repricing at the >10% customer (13.9% of FY2025 revenue) and Synchronoss's carriers (top five 97.6% of its revenue) renewing at lower prices. Sources: lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs, sncr-fy2024-10k, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| organicGrowth, years 3–10 | -0.010 | After the project slump, maintenance erodes slowly as the linear-advertising cohort declines and some customers migrate. No year since 2023 has shown maintenance below −1%. Sources: lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| organicMargin, years 1–10 | 0.255 | The H1 2026 dip persists, plus one point of pricing pressure from concentrated customers renewing (the >10% customer; Verizon and AT&T at Synchronoss). Sources: lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs, sncr-fy2024-10k |
| priceToSales, years 1–10 | 2.000 | Deals priced like WideOrbit (2.09x, the highest in the record) or like public take-privates at premiums, as competition for comms and media software rises. Sources: lumine-fy2023-mda, csi-synchronoss-release-2025 |
| acquiredMargin, years 1–3 | 0.170 | Synchronoss-like deals stay near their standalone margin (16.4%) because concentrated carrier customers capture the savings. Sources: sncr-fy2024-10k, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| acquiredMargin, years 4–10 | 0.200 | Partial strengthening only. At a 2.0x price this is a 10% yield, about the cost of capital and close to the earlier family-aggregate stress (8.6%). Sources: lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| acquiredGrowth, years 1–10 | -0.020 | Acquired businesses decline like WideOrbit's licence base in FY2024. Sources: lumine-fy2024-mda |
| deploymentCapacity, years 1–2 | 23.001 | A two-year dry spell at FY2021's 16.4 (the record's quietest year), longer than the record's longest quiet run of one year, while 2026-vintage prices stay high and the 2026 debt is repaid. 5 November debate: the same fixed seller-supply ceiling applies in every scenario; excess cash remains retained. Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda |
| deploymentCapacity, years 3–3 | 105.567 | 4 November Q3 update: 0.2397 × model year-3 owner cash (440.327 CAD m). Stated budget 105.567 CAD m, solved from the shared forecast without using an IRR target. The ratio is the lower internally funded FY2022–FY2025 observation. Actual purchases also remain limited by cash after claims. 5 November debate: the same fixed seller-supply ceiling applies in every scenario; excess cash remains retained. Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| deploymentCapacity, years 4–4 | 108.613 | 4 November Q3 update: 0.2397 × model year-4 owner cash (453.031 CAD m). Stated budget 108.613 CAD m, solved from the shared forecast without using an IRR target. The ratio is the lower internally funded FY2022–FY2025 observation. Actual purchases also remain limited by cash after claims. 5 November debate: the same fixed seller-supply ceiling applies in every scenario; excess cash remains retained. Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| deploymentCapacity, years 5–5 | 111.357 | 4 November Q3 update: 0.2397 × model year-5 owner cash (464.479 CAD m). Stated budget 111.357 CAD m, solved from the shared forecast without using an IRR target. The ratio is the lower internally funded FY2022–FY2025 observation. Actual purchases also remain limited by cash after claims. 5 November debate: the same fixed seller-supply ceiling applies in every scenario; excess cash remains retained. Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| deploymentCapacity, years 6–6 | 114.148 | 4 November Q3 update: 0.2397 × model year-6 owner cash (476.119 CAD m). Stated budget 114.148 CAD m, solved from the shared forecast without using an IRR target. The ratio is the lower internally funded FY2022–FY2025 observation. Actual purchases also remain limited by cash after claims. 5 November debate: the same fixed seller-supply ceiling applies in every scenario; excess cash remains retained. Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| deploymentCapacity, years 7–7 | 116.986 | 4 November Q3 update: 0.2397 × model year-7 owner cash (487.957 CAD m). Stated budget 116.986 CAD m, solved from the shared forecast without using an IRR target. The ratio is the lower internally funded FY2022–FY2025 observation. Actual purchases also remain limited by cash after claims. 5 November debate: the same fixed seller-supply ceiling applies in every scenario; excess cash remains retained. Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| deploymentCapacity, years 8–8 | 119.872 | 4 November Q3 update: 0.2397 × model year-8 owner cash (499.997 CAD m). Stated budget 119.872 CAD m, solved from the shared forecast without using an IRR target. The ratio is the lower internally funded FY2022–FY2025 observation. Actual purchases also remain limited by cash after claims. 5 November debate: the same fixed seller-supply ceiling applies in every scenario; excess cash remains retained. Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| deploymentCapacity, years 9–9 | 122.809 | 4 November Q3 update: 0.2397 × model year-9 owner cash (512.244 CAD m). Stated budget 122.809 CAD m, solved from the shared forecast without using an IRR target. The ratio is the lower internally funded FY2022–FY2025 observation. Actual purchases also remain limited by cash after claims. 5 November debate: the same fixed seller-supply ceiling applies in every scenario; excess cash remains retained. Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| deploymentCapacity, years 10–10 | 125.796 | 4 November Q3 update: 0.2397 × model year-10 owner cash (524.703 CAD m). Stated budget 125.796 CAD m, solved from the shared forecast without using an IRR target. The ratio is the lower internally funded FY2022–FY2025 observation. Actual purchases also remain limited by cash after claims. 5 November debate: the same fixed seller-supply ceiling applies in every scenario; excess cash remains retained. Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| exitMultiple, years 1–1 | 8.577 | Finite5-year postexit acquisition/organic opportunity at 11.0%required return; fixed seller ceiling and explicit capital costs. Scale changes the multiple by year. The duration and required return are subjective judgments. Full annual ledger is in the 5 November debate model-change record. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
| exitMultiple, years 2–2 | 8.573 | Finite5-year postexit acquisition/organic opportunity at 11.0%required return; fixed seller ceiling and explicit capital costs. Scale changes the multiple by year. The duration and required return are subjective judgments. Full annual ledger is in the 5 November debate model-change record. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
| exitMultiple, years 3–3 | 8.566 | Finite5-year postexit acquisition/organic opportunity at 11.0%required return; fixed seller ceiling and explicit capital costs. Scale changes the multiple by year. The duration and required return are subjective judgments. Full annual ledger is in the 5 November debate model-change record. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
| exitMultiple, years 4–4 | 8.558 | Finite5-year postexit acquisition/organic opportunity at 11.0%required return; fixed seller ceiling and explicit capital costs. Scale changes the multiple by year. The duration and required return are subjective judgments. Full annual ledger is in the 5 November debate model-change record. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
| exitMultiple, years 5–5 | 8.551 | Finite5-year postexit acquisition/organic opportunity at 11.0%required return; fixed seller ceiling and explicit capital costs. Scale changes the multiple by year. The duration and required return are subjective judgments. Full annual ledger is in the 5 November debate model-change record. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
| exitMultiple, years 6–6 | 8.544 | Finite5-year postexit acquisition/organic opportunity at 11.0%required return; fixed seller ceiling and explicit capital costs. Scale changes the multiple by year. The duration and required return are subjective judgments. Full annual ledger is in the 5 November debate model-change record. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
| exitMultiple, years 7–7 | 8.537 | Finite5-year postexit acquisition/organic opportunity at 11.0%required return; fixed seller ceiling and explicit capital costs. Scale changes the multiple by year. The duration and required return are subjective judgments. Full annual ledger is in the 5 November debate model-change record. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
| exitMultiple, years 8–8 | 8.531 | Finite5-year postexit acquisition/organic opportunity at 11.0%required return; fixed seller ceiling and explicit capital costs. Scale changes the multiple by year. The duration and required return are subjective judgments. Full annual ledger is in the 5 November debate model-change record. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
| exitMultiple, years 9–9 | 8.525 | Finite5-year postexit acquisition/organic opportunity at 11.0%required return; fixed seller ceiling and explicit capital costs. Scale changes the multiple by year. The duration and required return are subjective judgments. Full annual ledger is in the 5 November debate model-change record. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
| exitMultiple, years 10–10 | 8.519 | Finite5-year postexit acquisition/organic opportunity at 11.0%required return; fixed seller ceiling and explicit capital costs. Scale changes the multiple by year. The duration and required return are subjective judgments. Full annual ledger is in the 5 November debate model-change record. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
An explicit favorable case, not issuer guidance: 3% baseline cash growth, purchases 15% cheaper per unit of cash earnings and a 20% higher exit multiple. Full reinvestment still requires funded purchases and the declared timing policy. Purchase economics are financing-neutral with respect to legacy group debt; owner cash retains that debt cost. Terminal value uses finite postexit cash and capped annual purchases, with the researched year-specific multiple path; peer multiples are reference evidence only.
| Driver | Value/path | Reason and sources |
|---|---|---|
| payoutRatio | 0.000 | Zero reflects no declared dividend and management’s stated goal to reinvest FCFA2S. Operating FCF is not a shareholder receipt. An explicit favorable case, not issuer guidance: 3% baseline cash growth, purchases 15% cheaper per unit of cash earnings and a 20% higher exit multiple. Full reinvestment still requires funded purchases and the declared timing policy. Sources: lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda |
| dilutionRate | 0.000 | Zero additional dilution: issued shares were unchanged in FY2025 and H1 2026; no preferred conversion is still outstanding. Future issuance or compensation policy can change this assumption. An explicit favorable case, not issuer guidance: 3% baseline cash growth, purchases 15% cheaper per unit of cash earnings and a 20% higher exit multiple. Full reinvestment still requires funded purchases and the declared timing policy. Sources: lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda |
| reinvestmentRate | 1.000 | Base/upside 100% follows the stated FCFA2S reinvestment objective. The 50% stress retains cash for liquidity; retained cash adds to terminal equity once. An explicit favorable case, not issuer guidance: 3% baseline cash growth, purchases 15% cheaper per unit of cash earnings and a 20% higher exit multiple. Full reinvestment still requires funded purchases and the declared timing policy. Sources: lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda |
| organicGrowth, years 1–1 | 0.020 | Maintenance at the FY2025 rate (+2-3%), with licences and services recovering from the H1 2026 dip (services −13% in Q2). Sources: lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| organicGrowth, years 2–10 | 0.030 | Maintenance +3% (the TTM June 2026 reported rate) plus Synchronoss's subscriber-driven growth (5.7% in FY2024) and an upgrade cycle in broadcast IP and cloud playout, where Imagine and Quortex compete. Sources: lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, sncr-fy2024-10k, imagine-elta-2026, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| organicMargin, years 1–1 | 0.275 | Strengthening costs roll off faster than in the base. Sources: lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs |
| organicMargin, years 2–10 | 0.290 | Returns to the FY2025 financing-neutral margin less the current interest drag: 31.7% − 2.6% ≈ 29%. Sources: lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
| priceToSales, years 1–1 | 1.600 | At the upside's larger deal scale the deals are large ones, priced like Synchronoss (1.60x all-in to FY2024 revenue, sncrPriceToSales), the 2026 benchmark. Sources: sncr-fy2024-10k, lumine-q2-2026-fs |
| priceToSales, years 2–10 | 1.550 | A budget near the USD520m supply ceiling means large deals, not small carve-outs. Lumine's large deals averaged about 1.58x revenue: WideOrbit 2.09x, Synchronoss 1.60x, Motive about 1.05x including working capital. That is the 1.57x record (recPriceToSales). Small deals at 0.45-0.65x (Vidispine, Datafusion) can't fill this budget, so the upside gets no price advantage over the base; its edge is faster strengthening (acquired margin). Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda |
| acquiredMargin, years 1–1 | 0.240 | Faster strengthening of the 2026 deals. Sources: lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| acquiredMargin, years 2–3 | 0.280 | As base, slightly faster. Sources: lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| acquiredMargin, years 4–10 | 0.310 | The FY2025 record level for acquired revenue (31.2%, recAcquiredMarginLow) and the group's financing-neutral margin (31.7%). At 1.3x this is a 23.8% yield, near the record midpoint (23.3%). Sources: lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| acquiredGrowth, years 1–3 | 0.000 | Flat during strengthening, as in the base. Sources: lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
| acquiredGrowth, years 4–10 | 0.010 | Once strengthened, acquired businesses grow with maintenance (+1-3%). Sources: lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs |
| deploymentCapacity, years 1–1 | 673.126 | 4 November Q3 update: 1.3963 × model year-1 owner cash (482.071 CAD m), bounded by the fixed 730.073 CAD m deal-supply ceiling. Stated budget 673.126 CAD m, solved from the shared forecast without using an IRR target. The ratio is the historical FY2022–FY2025 all-in ratio; it does not authorize new borrowing. Actual purchases also remain limited by cash after claims. 5 November debate: the same fixed seller-supply ceiling applies in every scenario; excess cash remains retained. Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| deploymentCapacity, years 2–2 | 730.073 | 4 November Q3 update: 1.3963 × model year-2 owner cash (680.890 CAD m), bounded by the fixed 730.073 CAD m deal-supply ceiling. Stated budget 730.073 CAD m, solved from the shared forecast without using an IRR target. The ratio is the historical FY2022–FY2025 all-in ratio; it does not authorize new borrowing. Actual purchases also remain limited by cash after claims. 5 November debate: the same fixed seller-supply ceiling applies in every scenario; excess cash remains retained. Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| deploymentCapacity, years 3–3 | 730.073 | 4 November Q3 update: 1.3963 × model year-3 owner cash (820.981 CAD m), bounded by the fixed 730.073 CAD m deal-supply ceiling. Stated budget 730.073 CAD m, solved from the shared forecast without using an IRR target. The ratio is the historical FY2022–FY2025 all-in ratio; it does not authorize new borrowing. Actual purchases also remain limited by cash after claims. 5 November debate: the same fixed seller-supply ceiling applies in every scenario; excess cash remains retained. Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| deploymentCapacity, years 4–4 | 730.073 | 4 November Q3 update: 1.3963 × model year-4 owner cash (1019.147 CAD m), bounded by the fixed 730.073 CAD m deal-supply ceiling. Stated budget 730.073 CAD m, solved from the shared forecast without using an IRR target. The ratio is the historical FY2022–FY2025 all-in ratio; it does not authorize new borrowing. Actual purchases also remain limited by cash after claims. 5 November debate: the same fixed seller-supply ceiling applies in every scenario; excess cash remains retained. Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| deploymentCapacity, years 5–5 | 730.073 | 4 November Q3 update: 1.3963 × model year-5 owner cash (1194.554 CAD m), bounded by the fixed 730.073 CAD m deal-supply ceiling. Stated budget 730.073 CAD m, solved from the shared forecast without using an IRR target. The ratio is the historical FY2022–FY2025 all-in ratio; it does not authorize new borrowing. Actual purchases also remain limited by cash after claims. 5 November debate: the same fixed seller-supply ceiling applies in every scenario; excess cash remains retained. Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| deploymentCapacity, years 6–6 | 730.073 | 4 November Q3 update: 1.3963 × model year-6 owner cash (1369.559 CAD m), bounded by the fixed 730.073 CAD m deal-supply ceiling. Stated budget 730.073 CAD m, solved from the shared forecast without using an IRR target. The ratio is the historical FY2022–FY2025 all-in ratio; it does not authorize new borrowing. Actual purchases also remain limited by cash after claims. 5 November debate: the same fixed seller-supply ceiling applies in every scenario; excess cash remains retained. Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| deploymentCapacity, years 7–7 | 730.073 | 4 November Q3 update: 1.3963 × model year-7 owner cash (1543.554 CAD m), bounded by the fixed 730.073 CAD m deal-supply ceiling. Stated budget 730.073 CAD m, solved from the shared forecast without using an IRR target. The ratio is the historical FY2022–FY2025 all-in ratio; it does not authorize new borrowing. Actual purchases also remain limited by cash after claims. 5 November debate: the same fixed seller-supply ceiling applies in every scenario; excess cash remains retained. Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| deploymentCapacity, years 8–8 | 730.073 | 4 November Q3 update: 1.3963 × model year-8 owner cash (1721.421 CAD m), bounded by the fixed 730.073 CAD m deal-supply ceiling. Stated budget 730.073 CAD m, solved from the shared forecast without using an IRR target. The ratio is the historical FY2022–FY2025 all-in ratio; it does not authorize new borrowing. Actual purchases also remain limited by cash after claims. 5 November debate: the same fixed seller-supply ceiling applies in every scenario; excess cash remains retained. Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| deploymentCapacity, years 9–9 | 730.073 | 4 November Q3 update: 1.3963 × model year-9 owner cash (1903.230 CAD m), bounded by the fixed 730.073 CAD m deal-supply ceiling. Stated budget 730.073 CAD m, solved from the shared forecast without using an IRR target. The ratio is the historical FY2022–FY2025 all-in ratio; it does not authorize new borrowing. Actual purchases also remain limited by cash after claims. 5 November debate: the same fixed seller-supply ceiling applies in every scenario; excess cash remains retained. Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| deploymentCapacity, years 10–10 | 730.073 | 4 November Q3 update: 1.3963 × model year-10 owner cash (2089.053 CAD m), bounded by the fixed 730.073 CAD m deal-supply ceiling. Stated budget 730.073 CAD m, solved from the shared forecast without using an IRR target. The ratio is the historical FY2022–FY2025 all-in ratio; it does not authorize new borrowing. Actual purchases also remain limited by cash after claims. 5 November debate: the same fixed seller-supply ceiling applies in every scenario; excess cash remains retained. Sources: lumine-fy2022-mda, lumine-fy2023-mda, lumine-fy2024-mda, lumine-fy2025-mda, lumine-q2-2026-fs, lumine-q2-2026-mda, lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda |
| exitMultiple, years 1–1 | 31.125 | Finite15-year postexit acquisition/organic opportunity at 8.5%required return; fixed seller ceiling and explicit capital costs. Scale changes the multiple by year. The duration and required return are subjective judgments. Full annual ledger is in the 5 November debate model-change record. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
| exitMultiple, years 2–2 | 27.438 | Finite15-year postexit acquisition/organic opportunity at 8.5%required return; fixed seller ceiling and explicit capital costs. Scale changes the multiple by year. The duration and required return are subjective judgments. Full annual ledger is in the 5 November debate model-change record. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
| exitMultiple, years 3–3 | 24.911 | Finite15-year postexit acquisition/organic opportunity at 8.5%required return; fixed seller ceiling and explicit capital costs. Scale changes the multiple by year. The duration and required return are subjective judgments. Full annual ledger is in the 5 November debate model-change record. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
| exitMultiple, years 4–4 | 22.868 | Finite15-year postexit acquisition/organic opportunity at 8.5%required return; fixed seller ceiling and explicit capital costs. Scale changes the multiple by year. The duration and required return are subjective judgments. Full annual ledger is in the 5 November debate model-change record. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
| exitMultiple, years 5–5 | 21.591 | Finite15-year postexit acquisition/organic opportunity at 8.5%required return; fixed seller ceiling and explicit capital costs. Scale changes the multiple by year. The duration and required return are subjective judgments. Full annual ledger is in the 5 November debate model-change record. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
| exitMultiple, years 6–6 | 20.600 | Finite15-year postexit acquisition/organic opportunity at 8.5%required return; fixed seller ceiling and explicit capital costs. Scale changes the multiple by year. The duration and required return are subjective judgments. Full annual ledger is in the 5 November debate model-change record. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
| exitMultiple, years 7–7 | 19.809 | Finite15-year postexit acquisition/organic opportunity at 8.5%required return; fixed seller ceiling and explicit capital costs. Scale changes the multiple by year. The duration and required return are subjective judgments. Full annual ledger is in the 5 November debate model-change record. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
| exitMultiple, years 8–8 | 19.162 | Finite15-year postexit acquisition/organic opportunity at 8.5%required return; fixed seller ceiling and explicit capital costs. Scale changes the multiple by year. The duration and required return are subjective judgments. Full annual ledger is in the 5 November debate model-change record. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
| exitMultiple, years 9–9 | 18.624 | Finite15-year postexit acquisition/organic opportunity at 8.5%required return; fixed seller ceiling and explicit capital costs. Scale changes the multiple by year. The duration and required return are subjective judgments. Full annual ledger is in the 5 November debate model-change record. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
| exitMultiple, years 10–10 | 18.169 | Finite15-year postexit acquisition/organic opportunity at 8.5%required return; fixed seller ceiling and explicit capital costs. Scale changes the multiple by year. The duration and required return are subjective judgments. Full annual ledger is in the 5 November debate model-change record. Sources: lumine-q3-2026-fs, lumine-q3-2026-mda, lumine-fy2025-fs |
Next reported quarter and FY2026 accounts (date not confirmed): acquired cash margins, organic recurring sales, cash taxes/debt, target deal prices and accessible liquidity; 24 November technology conference is not an earnings report.
Reassess after coherent capped scenarios and independent terminal definitions; retain existing coarse horizon-specific weights because stronger Q3 cash and persistent integration/customer/refinancing risks do not establish revised numerical frequencies. No odds fitted to returns.
Detailed claim-by-claim judgment. All shared-engine calculations retain stable fact IDs and audit links; original source arithmetic is not a current forecast.
4 November 2026, September accounts. USD millions unless stated; model currency CAD, fixed translation 1.4025. Economic decisions below were recorded before comparing revised IRRs. Dated evidence and attribution.
| Opportunity | Current evidence | Reachable change and cost | Limits and contrary evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Recurring renewals and pricing | Q3 recurring organic growth 6%; total organic constant-currency growth 3%, trailing 1% | Modest base growth: 1% next year, 2% years 2–5, 1.5% later; continuing support/R&D remains charged | No portfolio retention or renewal-price series; customers can consolidate vendors or change technology. A strong recurring quarter is not a ten-year growth rate. |
| Licences and services | Q3 organic FX-adjusted growth −14% and −10% | Base growth remains modest; upgrades require implementation staff and customer budgets | New platforms can replace existing products; no extrapolation of 55% reported acquisition-led growth. |
| Synchronoss already owned | Q3 revenue 43.137, owned YTD 107.446 | Flat-quarter annualization leaves 65.102 missing sales, estimated cash at the financing-neutral group margin; cash recovery ramps over one year | Target cash margin not disclosed; concentrated carriers have renewal leverage. Q3 net income includes acquisition accounting and is not owner cash. |
| July businesses already owned | Quortex/Imagine first full owned-quarter sales 21.511/35.611 | Three missing quarters add 171.366 revenue; cash converges separately over one year | Imagine lost 6.826; Quortex profit includes a 4.904 bargain gain. No observed mature cash margin. Do not buy these businesses twice. |
| Future acquisitions | Measured through-cycle deal record and matched funding observations | Base first two annual budgets stay USD81.85m; later budgets 0.6845 × annual owner cash, stated as dollar paths. Downside starts with the two small-budget years and later uses 0.2397; upside uses 1.3963 but cannot exceed USD520.551m supply or available cash | Ratios are observations, not targets or seller commitments. The recent peak is only an upside supply ceiling. All-in prices, timing and strengthening costs matter. |
| Unplaced cash | Q3 debt repayments 59.375; no common dividend | Retain cash; debt-saving return capped at gross principal 425.625, measured deposit yield above | No extra borrowing assumed. Subsidiary restrictions, liquidity needs, debt maturity and a future dividend/buyback can alter allocation. |
| Customer budget risk | Amdocs 3 November report: lost/disputed T-Mobile work, discretionary cuts, weaker pro-forma outlook | Watch Lumine's maintenance, concentration and contract evidence | This is an independent counterparty warning, not proof Lumine lost a customer. Peer perimeter changes cannot become Lumine organic decline. |
Current5 November 2026 judgment: The reported September bridge and existing staged organic/target margins remain. Every scenario now shares the fixed CAD730.073m annual seller-supply ceiling; cash does not establish more sellers. Retained cash remains separate and earns the specified capped debt-saving/deposit return. Subsequent annual target purchases are funded without new borrowing. The base’s later budgets stop at the same seller limit as upside.
Customer attrition, lower target cash margins, expensive purchases and a short profitable opportunity period jointly reduce owner value. The current low-growth/low-margin path and five-year finite tail express this mechanism. Tax timing is not made into a permanent benefit, no new facility is inferred from covenant compliance, and uncapped earnouts/access to subsidiary cash remain unresolved. Zero common recovery and financing failure can still occur outside the representative paths.
The forward opportunity ledger determines the operating path before return comparisons. It is not a projection of past CAGR or management targets. Capital, timing and ownership claims remain matched to the revenue/cash perimeter. Reassess after coherent capped scenarios and independent terminal definitions; retain existing coarse horizon-specific weights because stronger Q3 cash and persistent integration/customer/refinancing risks do not establish revised numerical frequencies. No odds fitted to returns.
5-year base: revenue 2669.164, owner cash 794.988, exit cash earnings 813.709 (CADm). 10-year base: revenue 5006.865, owner cash 1515.798, exit cash earnings 1530.533 (CADm).
Each forecast year has its own terminal owner-cash multiple. The adverse/base/favorable tails run 5/10/15 additional years at 11%/9.5%/8.5% required owner returns. They continue the scenario’s operating margins and modest organic/acquired growth, charge each purchase once, cap annual purchase capital by seller supply and owner cash, then assume no further growth or acquisitions. Current retained cash is valued separately once; no second bank-debt deduction is made from after-financing equity cash. Base multiples are 17.277× at the five-year exit and 14.250× at the ten-year exit: a fixed dollar opportunity is worth less per earnings dollar as the portfolio grows. Duration and discount rates are low-confidence judgments. The annual revenue/cash/capital ledger and 0/5/10/15-year duration sensitivities are inspectable in the model-change record; local sensitivities hold this researched tail fixed.
No return target determines this path. Source locators and disagreements are in 12-debate.md and 07-assumption-register.md.
Assessment:5 November 2026. Values below come directly from the same shared forecast used by the dashboard. Money is in CAD millions.
| Horizon | Scenario | Capital-return definition | Return/proxy | Period-weighted reinvestment | Growth capital | Matching earnings | Funding residual |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 years | downside | Acquisition ROIIC · mature cash proxy | 9.39% | 17.07% | 371.539 | 2176.335 | 2.27e-13 |
| 5 years | base | Acquisition ROIIC · mature cash proxy | 18.16% | 54.80% | 1641.902 | 2996.242 | 6.82e-13 |
| 5 years | upside | Acquisition ROIIC · mature cash proxy | 18.28% | 84.67% | 3554.196 | 4197.642 | 4.55e-13 |
| 10 years | downside | Acquisition ROIIC · mature cash proxy | 9.77% | 20.76% | 971.150 | 4677.354 | 5.68e-13 |
| 10 years | base | Acquisition ROIIC · mature cash proxy | 18.98% | 57.24% | 5183.857 | 9055.914 | 9.09e-13 |
| 10 years | upside | Acquisition ROIIC · mature cash proxy | 19.15% | 56.18% | 7204.559 | 12824.457 | 0.00e+0 |
The acquisition return is purchased mature owner cash / new acquisition capital, not measured historical cohort ROIIC or a discounted project IRR. Previously funded businesses are not bought again. Ongoing product/development investment remains expensed and unquantified as growth capital, so acquisition reinvestment is not total economic reinvestment. Unused cash and debt-saving/deposit returns are separate from bought operating earnings.
Reinvestment equals total new growth investment divided by total matching earnings over the period, not the average of annual percentages. Cash generation less distributions/old claims plus opening cash drawn and net borrowing reconciles to new investment. No extra borrowing or invented working-capital release is introduced. All six funding ledgers reconcile within 0.000001 model millions.
Sources and definitions:04-capital-allocation.md, valuation/calculations.json and the shared ledger; docs/method/cash-flow-and-reinvestment.md. Dated review.
Assessment:5 November 2026, after the independent debate. Low-confidence subjective joint-path weights; no claim of empirical calibration or source-author odds.
| Horizon | Bear | Base | Bull |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5 years | 30.00% | 50.00% | 20.00% |
| 10 years | 35.00% | 40.00% | 25.00% |
Reassess after coherent capped scenarios and independent terminal definitions; retain existing coarse horizon-specific weights because stronger Q3 cash and persistent integration/customer/refinancing risks do not establish revised numerical frequencies. No odds fitted to returns.
The reported September bridge and existing staged organic/target margins remain. Every scenario now shares the fixed CAD730.073m annual seller-supply ceiling; cash does not establish more sellers. Retained cash remains separate and earns the specified capped debt-saving/deposit return. Subsequent annual target purchases are funded without new borrowing. The base’s later budgets stop at the same seller limit as upside. Customer attrition, lower target cash margins, expensive purchases and a short profitable opportunity period jointly reduce owner value. The current low-growth/low-margin path and five-year finite tail express this mechanism. Tax timing is not made into a permanent benefit, no new facility is inferred from covenant compliance, and uncapped earnouts/access to subsidiary cash remain unresolved. Zero common recovery and financing failure can still occur outside the representative paths.
Moderate in the recurring-software acquisition mechanism, low in precise target margins, accessible funding and postexit duration. Q3 accounts strengthen the starting bridge but do not prove future target supply or ten-year returns. Review on Next reported quarter and FY2026 accounts (date not confirmed): acquired cash margins, organic recurring sales, cash taxes/debt, target deal prices and accessible liquidity; 24 November technology conference is not an earnings report.
Weights sum to 100% independently for each horizon. These paths represent outcome regions and omit permanent-loss tails. Price alone does not change business-path odds; local scenario overrides suspend researched weights. Weighted IRR is calculated from probability-weighted dated shareholder receipts, not by averaging scenario IRRs. Evidence and rebuttals; method:docs/method/scenario-probabilities.md.
Independent advocates prepared opening cases without seeing the other draft, then exchanged point-by-point cross-examinations. A separate judge who did not author the prior model assessed the competing claims. Source reconstructions retain their stated provenance; inaccessible private reports were not newly read. Quoted sensitivities test arguments and are not automatically adopted forecasts.
Fixed quote CAD 26.36, market time 2026-11-04T20:59:59.000Z; valuation date 2026-11-05. Original forecast exits retained.
| Horizon | Before bear/base/bull | After bear/base/bull | Weighted before → after |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5 years | 0.82% / 18.96% / 32.54% | -3.18% / 18.40% / 32.91% | 18.34% → 17.57% |
| 10 years | 3.37% / 17.26% / 22.30% | 1.68% / 14.42% / 20.61% | 15.76% → 13.60% |
As of 5 November 2026. No opposing advocate draft was read. Existing company research, fact/calculation ledgers and exact registered source locators were examined; original issuer sources additionally checked live: Lumine Q3, CSU Q2, Diploma Q3 transcript, NVIDIA CFO commentary, TerraVest Highland/KBK, WOSG FY26. Harvia Q3 PDF retrieval failed; its registered extraction remains the evidence limit. Private source interpretations below are the repository's documented reconstruction, not a new claim to have read an unavailable private original.
The strongest bear case is a collection of legacy products earning cash while customer concentration, integration losses and financed acquisition growth hide deterioration. Cash and reported profit are not interchangeable, and the short acquisition record is dominated by a few deals.
LMN-B1 — The recurring base has not broken. Independently checked the 4 November issuer release: Q3 organic growth 3% versus 55% total; FCFA2S53.9m, up 27%. The MD&A recurring organic 6% versus shrinking licences/services supports the existing modest upside organic path, not acquisition-led55% extrapolation. Sources lumine-q3-2026-release, Q3 headlines and revenue discussion; lumine-q3-2026-mda, pp.4–8. Test upside organicGrowth only; maintain financing and target margins.
LMN-B2 — Owned sales can mature without another purchase. September reported cash 202.4 and gross debt 425.625 replace stale June closing estimates. Observed missing consolidated sales are 65.102 Synchronoss and 171.366 July businesses; estimated cash still ramps. Test upside organicMargin only, holding all owned-cohort ramps unchanged. Sources lumine-q3-2026-fs, pp.7,12–15,18–20; lumine-q3-2026-mda, pp.9–11. Imagine losses and Quortex bargain gain do not establish target cash. Base staged recovery already captures much of this bull mechanism; no second July purchase or full-year revenue double count is permitted.
LMN-B3 — Idle cash creates deployment optionality. Test upside annual deployment budgets, retaining base purchase prices and margins; actual cash remains a constraint. The USD520.551m ceiling bounds seller supply; first-two-year base USD81.85m budgets intentionally model quiet years. Historical FY2022–25 all-in ratio 1.3963 is a possibility, not permission to borrow. Sources lumine-fy2025-fs, acquisition/cash-flow notes; lumine-q3-2026-fs, acquisitions pp.11–15 and liquidity/debt pp.18–20; named deployment calculations. This is the largest model upside, therefore the strongest uncertainty.
LMN-B4 — The exit premium needs proof beyond peers. Test21.3× versus 17.73585×. Base17.74× requires~14 post-exit years at 10% growth, 19.35% marginal return and 9.5% required return. Specialised installed systems and carve-out sourcing are the claimed advantage; linear-media erosion and acquisition competition attack it. Peer cash-P/E definitions remain unresolved. This supports neither a higher central multiple nor high conviction.
Saved quote 26.36; market timestamp 2026-11-04T20:59:59.000Z. Fixed valuation date 2026-11-05; model 3f48908d71af; exits remain the original model vintage. These are sensitivities, not joint forecasts or probability revisions. Baseline base IRR 18.96% / 17.26% (5/10 years).
| Claim | Exact input/path | 5-year base | 10-year base | Change, pp (5/10) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| LMN-B1 | cases.base.inputs.yearly.organicGrowth | 19.57% | 17.71% | +0.62 / +0.45 |
| LMN-B2 | cases.base.inputs.yearly.organicMargin | 19.56% | 17.45% | +0.60 / +0.19 |
| LMN-B3 | cases.base.inputs.yearly.deploymentCapacity | 26.01% | 19.10% | +7.05 / +1.84 |
| LMN-B4 | cases.base.inputs.exitMultiple | 23.00% | 19.21% | +4.04 / +1.95 |
The recurring base grew 6% organically in Q3, purchased sales now have an observed full owned quarter, and USD59.375m of bank principal was repaid. If the acquired businesses approach the historical group margin while modestly priced bolt-ons continue, low organic growth can still produce attractive per-share compounding. This is a real cash mechanism, not a revenue-growth story.
The favorable return depends on three separate estimates that the new report does not establish: working-capital normalization, acquired-cash convergence, and a long reinvestment runway. Nine-month FCFA2S is USD129.7m, down 14%; trailing reported cash 196.7m becomes normalized 243.8m, then 309.3m after estimated mature missing-month contributions. The missing sales are observed; their group-like cash margins are not. Imagine's losses and Quortex's bargain gain make accounting profit an especially weak cash proxy. USD8.895m more current tax was accrued than paid in nine months. Treating all of the September cash as deployable and repeatedly refinancing 2028–2030 bank maturities adds a liquidity assumption; covenants met today do not resolve those later funding choices. [lumine-q3-2026-fs pp.12–15,18–20,23–24; lumine-q3-2026-mda pp.5–11; named calculations ownerCashUsd, missing-month cohort bridges in valuation/calculations.json.]
The outside view is mixed. The low-bound historical deal yield near 20% comes from a short, concentrated cohort. Synchronoss's estimated standalone cash yield was 10.3%, and five carriers supplied 97.6% of sales. A group margin cannot be transferred to a customer-concentrated acquisition without showing who retains the restructuring savings. [sncr-fy2024-10k customer concentration and cash statements; lumine-q2-2026-fs note 4; research/04-capital-allocation.md.]
The17.7x exit is a converted Topicus multiple from an investor table whose cash definition remains unresolved. The company's own value-driver check supports about 16x at 5% growth, 18% incremental return and 9.5% required return, while the no-runway value is about 11x. No evidenced count of post-2031 excess-return years supports 17.7x. A strong earnings quarter does not close that gap. Existing acquisition budgets also rise to aboutUSD787m in year 10, beyond the USD520.6m fixed seller-supply ceiling imposed only on the upside; an allocation ratio is not a seller-supply forecast.
The Q3 issuer release was reopened for this review; the other cited evidence is the source-linked repository reconstruction. No private customer contracts or target cash accounts were obtained. No automatic numerical change is warranted merely because a stress lowers returns; the judge must establish the burden for the current extrapolation.
Fixed saved quote CAD26.36; market timestamp 2026-11-04T20:59:59.000Z; valuation date 5 November 2026; fixed original exit calendar. Base before: 18.96% / 17.26% (5/10years). These are one-change sensitivities to the base, except named bundles; existing scenario probabilities are not revised or claimed as validated.
| Claim | Change | 5-year base IRR | 10-year base IRR | 5-year effect | 10-year effect |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| LMN-B1 | Base exit 16x | 16.77% | 16.19% | -2.18pp | -1.07pp |
| LMN-B2 | New acquired cash margin capped at 20% | 15.74% | 14.03% | -3.21pp | -3.23pp |
| LMN-B3 | Organic margin stays at September normalized cash margin | 17.94% | 16.94% | -1.01pp | -0.32pp |
| LMN-B4 | Base annual acquisition budgets 25% lower | 17.23% | 15.54% | -1.72pp | -1.72pp |
5 November 2026. Written after independently frozen openings were exchanged. Every numbered bear claim is addressed below; original bull openings and sensitivities remain unchanged.
lumine-q3-2026-fs, pp12–15 provides owned sales and acquisition losses/gains; no standalone acquired cash accounts establish 30%. Historical near 20% entry cash yields use multiple cohorts, but only a few years and large deals. Carrier concentration is real (sncr-fy2024-10k). My organic-margin sensitivity does not change funded-cohort cash ramps or relabel sales as cash. Treat20% as an adverse path unless transaction population evidence replaces the current future-margin path.lumine-q3-2026-mda, pp4–8), not proof of acquired-carrier retention or margin. Base26.2→27→27.8% requires cost absorption; current financed profitability and prior group margins support conditional partial recovery, not certainty. Software spending stays charged in all cases.5 November 2026; written after frozen independent openings were exchanged. Claim prefixes in the openings are local to each advocate; author identity distinguishes them.
lumine-q3-2026-mda, pp.4–8). They are not acquired-carrier retention, customer-level margin or a guarantee of future migrations. Retain modest organic paths; do not infer 55% organic expansion.lumine-q3-2026-fs, pp.12–15). Flat September margin is an adverse test, not an observed permanent normalization. Historical group margin supports a conditional partial recovery; I do not claim 20% must replace every future deal centrally.Existing estimates receive no presumption merely because they are already in the model. Positive company evidence, the relevant outside view and the capital/funding bridge determine each verdict; neither arbitrary conservatism nor an unsupported favorable sensitivity replaces it. The evidence and reconstruction below explain numerical changes or explicit no-change conclusions claim by claim.
| Contested claim | Verdict | Evidence/locator | Reason and model action |
|---|---|---|---|
| bull advocate: Recurring maintenance and owned acquisition sales support continued cash compounding | adopt-modified | lumine-q3-2026-mda pp.4–11; lumine-q3-2026-fs pp.12–15 | Keep the Q3 trailing-period cash/revenue/claims bridge, observed missing owned sales and separate estimated target-margin ramp.55% total growth includes acquisitions; do not promote it to organic growth or target net profit to owner cash. |
| bear advocate: Central annual acquisition budgets eventually exceed the seller ceiling applied to upside | adopt | lumine-fy2022-mda through lumine-fy2025-mda; lumine-q3-2026-fs pp.12–15; named supplyCeilingCad/internalDeployRatioSep26 | Apply the same 730.073 CADm annual seller limit to every scenario; cash is funding, not target supply. No25%arbitrary haircut or new borrowing. Capped later purchases leave unplaced cash visible. |
| bull advocate: A finite ongoing acquisition opportunity supports a premium to steady state | adopt-modified | lumine-playbook; lumine-fy2025-mda; lumine-q3-2026-fs/mda; measured acquired margins/price-to-sales in calculations | Value actual annual operating cash and acquisition capital through finite 5/10/15 postexit years at 11/9.5/8.5%required returns in adverse/central/favorable paths. All tail purchases obey seller supply and owner cash, then no-growth value. These duration/discount estimates are explicit judgments; no peer-table multiplier or return target. |
| bear advocate: A single 17.7x peer-linked multiple cannot fit both five- and ten-year scale under fixed seller supply | adopt | named peerExitMultiple (preserved reference); updates/2026-11-05-debate-model-change.json finite annual revenue/cash/capital ledger | Replace live peer binding with yearly terminal multiple paths. Central5/10-year multiples are 17.277x/14.250x under the fixed-dollar tail. Preserve peer arithmetic as comparison and source calibration; bridge/sensitivity/model sheet read actual dated multiples. |
| bear advocate: Owned sales do not establish mature cash margins, tax benefits or freely deployable subsidiary cash | unresolved | lumine-q3-2026-fs pp.7,12–15,18–25; lumine-q3-2026-mda pp.9–17 | No additional normalization, immediate target cash or arbitrary margin cut. Keep current staged recovery and explicit customer/refinancing/earnout/tax risks. Those survive the debate, constrain conviction and are already represented in adverse paths; they require future evidence. |
Reassess after coherent capped scenarios and independent terminal definitions; retain existing coarse horizon-specific weights because stronger Q3 cash and persistent integration/customer/refinancing risks do not establish revised numerical frequencies. No odds fitted to returns.
Moderate in the recurring-software acquisition mechanism, low in precise target margins, accessible funding and postexit duration. Q3 accounts strengthen the starting bridge but do not prove future target supply or ten-year returns. These are forward estimates with surviving attacks, not confirmed outcomes. Neither numerical calibration, a completed checklist nor passing software tests establishes investment skill. Reported facts stay separate from forward judgments, and adverse paths are not worst-case bounds.
What would change the view: Next reported quarter and FY2026 accounts (date not confirmed): acquired cash margins, organic recurring sales, cash taxes/debt, target deal prices and accessible liquidity; 24 November technology conference is not an earnings report.
Exact inputs, isolated sensitivities, model hashes and same-price/date before/after returns.
Primary filings, investor communications, and industry evidence.
Pages 2–3 balance sheet and revenue; 7 cash flows; 11–12 Synchronoss; 16–17 debt; 19 shares; 22 working capital; 23 July transactions
Published Aug 4, 2026 · Reviewed Oct 31, 2026Non-IFRS definitions; FCFA2S reconciliation; organic growth; capital resources and subsequent events
Published Aug 4, 2026 · Reviewed Oct 26, 2026Income and cash-flow statements; 2025 acquisitions; note 23 working capital; share conversion history
Published Mar 4, 2026 · Reviewed Oct 26, 2026FY2025 FCFA2S 217.0; revenue 765.7; non-IFRS definitions and cash allocation
Published Mar 4, 2026 · Reviewed Oct 26, 2026Mission-critical software, low churn, niche position and customer diversification; related operating playbook
Reviewed Oct 26, 2026FXUSDCAD 1.4025 CAD per USD; used consistently in monetary model inputs
Published Oct 26, 2026 · Reviewed Oct 26, 2026Yahoo chart metadata: symbol LMN.V; currency CAD; market price 26.15; market timestamp 26 October 2026 20:00 UTC. Free unofficial delayed source.
Published Oct 26, 2026 · Reviewed Oct 26, 2026Checked 2 November: latest financial release remains 4 August Q2; no later financial/acquisition/financing disclosure located.
Reviewed Nov 2, 2026pp.8, 18-23: cash-flow identity, intangible capital and lagged multi-year ROIIC. Calculation guidance, not company-specific forecast assumptions.
Published Oct 6, 2022 · Reviewed Oct 27, 2026Cash-in/cash-out and economic compensation; multi-year retained capital, incremental earnings, limitations. A signed worked framework, not a source for the company numerical inputs.
Published Aug 26, 2023 · Reviewed Oct 27, 2026Printed pages 894-897: coherent scenarios, estimating probabilities and scenario-weighted cash flows. No company probability is supplied.
Reviewed Not reviewedStatutory filings, other financial news and the embedded original public financial table.
Reviewed Nov 2, 2026Acquisitions, portfolio products and customer-facing activity
Published Oct 20, 2026 · Reviewed Oct 28, 2026Upcoming and past events
Reviewed Nov 2, 2026Organic sales, segment margins, cash and market outlook
Published Oct 15, 2026 · Reviewed Oct 27, 2026Full attached report: Core Software, segment notes, timing and server constraints
Published Oct 22, 2026 · Reviewed Oct 27, 2026Operator service revenue, churn, cash, capital expenditures and outlook
Published Oct 26, 2026 · Reviewed Oct 27, 2026Financial-performance landing page; financial tables dynamically rendered
Reviewed Oct 30, 2026Checked current publication index: featured articles remain 29 October; one 30 October modification label. Operating Q3 newsletter is not financial accounts.
Reviewed Nov 2, 2026Latest located group financial release and linked Q2 financial documents
Published Aug 4, 2026 · Reviewed Oct 28, 2026Service revenue, operating cash, capex, adjusted FCF and reconciliation/definition notes
Published Oct 28, 2026 · Reviewed Oct 28, 2026Full article: software-defined connectivity, edge economics, live operational data, security and sovereignty.
Published Oct 29, 2026 · Reviewed Oct 29, 2026Full article: RCTO partnership and support for five Ontario organizations in 2026.
Published Oct 29, 2026 · Reviewed Oct 31, 2026Full issuer release: connectivity/media drivers, business perimeter and cash-flow tables.
Published Oct 22, 2026 · Reviewed Oct 29, 2026Read-only endpoint embedded in issuer statutory-filings page. Seven resource rows; 2026 release, financial-statement and MD&A links stop at Q2; Q3/Q4 are unlinked labels.
Reviewed Nov 2, 2026Full original release; product/service revenue, GAAP/non-GAAP reconciliation, balance sheet and nine-month cash flow.
Published Oct 27, 2026 · Reviewed Oct 30, 2026Issuer investor home and October 7 notice: Q3 results call on 6 November 2026, 08:30 EST.
Published Oct 7, 2026 · Reviewed Oct 30, 2026Note 7, printed pp.16–17: Telarix termination/repayment and dated loan schedule.
Published Nov 3, 2025 · Reviewed Oct 31, 2026Full original release: Altitude Playout Plus, Channel 4 agreement and 2027 launch, hybrid/cloud deployment.
Published Aug 28, 2026 · Reviewed Oct 31, 2026Upcoming November 12 commercial events, October NAB participation; linked webinar index lists November 17 programmatic-radio session.
Reviewed Oct 31, 2026Full original portfolio-company release: customer upgrade, existing workflows, local implementation partner and product configuration.
Published Sep 10, 2026 · Reviewed Nov 1, 2026Full original 2 November release and About the report section; original HTML recovered by HTTP 200 download.
Published Nov 2, 2026 · Reviewed Nov 2, 2026Full original financial release: organic operating growth, free cash before/after M&A, Nordic outlook and capital spending.
Published Oct 28, 2026 · Reviewed Nov 2, 2026Full Telenor statutory announcement distributed by Oslo Børs, recovered on MFN after linked NewsWeb page required JavaScript.
Published Nov 2, 2026 · Reviewed Nov 2, 2026PDF p.4 organic growth; p.10 Topicus Coop preference units; p.12 FCFA2S reconciliation (2021 and 2020); p.15 cash used in acquisitions (2021 and 2020).
Reviewed Nov 3, 2026PDF p.6 organic growth; p.18 cash used in acquisitions.
Reviewed Nov 3, 2026PDF p.5 organic growth; p.18 cash used in acquisitions.
Reviewed Nov 3, 2026PDF p.5 organic growth and quarterly organic table; p.13 FCFA2S reconciliation (2025 and 2024); p.18 cash used in acquisitions (2025 and 2024).
Reviewed Nov 3, 2026PDF p.3 WideOrbit purchase price, special shares and parent cash funding; p.14 preferred shares issued for cash proceeds.
Reviewed Nov 3, 2026PDF p.4 results table (2024, 2023); p.5 revenue by type and organic growth, one customer >10% (US$71.5m); p.6-7 expenses and staff by department (2024, 2023); p.11 FCFA2S reconciliation; p.12-13 liquidity, most significant customer receivable US$44.3m, net cash-flow table.
Published Mar 4, 2025 · Reviewed Nov 3, 2026PDF p.2-3 results table (2022, 2021 combined carve-out basis); p.3 organic growth -9% and the 2022 acquisition with known pre-acquisition attrition; p.8 quarterly revenue 2021-2022; p.9 net cash-flow table (2022, 2021).
Published Mar 1, 2023 · Reviewed Nov 3, 2026Price up to EUR185m including up to EUR35m contingent on first-year performance; revenue and employees not disclosed in the release.
Published Dec 20, 2023 · Reviewed Nov 3, 2026Income statement (net revenues 173.594, income from operations 21.682); cash-flow statement (operating cash 28.280, fixed assets 1.896, capitalized software 13.027); supplemental cash interest 15.130; customer concentration note (top five 97.6% of revenue; Verizon and AT&T each >10%).
Published Mar 11, 2025 · Reviewed Nov 3, 2026US$9.00 per share cash; equity value about US$116.4m; enterprise value about US$258.4m; about 70% premium to 3 December close.
Published Dec 4, 2025 · Reviewed Nov 3, 2026Lumine conversion paragraph: CSU consolidates Lumine with a 61.40% equity interest and holds 157,553,539 subordinate voting shares at 31 March 2024.
Published Aug 8, 2024 · Reviewed Nov 3, 2026Seven directors: Mark Miller (chair; CSU President and COO), David Nyland (CEO), Brian Beattie (Volaris CFO/COO), Laurie Schultz (CSU director), Eric Mathewson (WideOrbit founder), Lucie Laplante (audit chair, independent), Paul Cowling (independent; Cogeco).
Reviewed Nov 3, 2026Independent directors Laplante and Cowling; independent observers from Spring Fibre and Proximus.
Published Feb 7, 2023 · Reviewed Nov 3, 2026Yahoo chart API: 3-month daily closes and volumes (median 126,750 shares, median traded value about C$2.9m a day to 3 November 2026); monthly closes since April 2023 (high about C$55 in July 2025, low about C$19.4 in April 2026).
Published Nov 3, 2026 · Reviewed Nov 3, 2026Q3 2026 period; publication date not disclosed. M&A Activity, Portfolio Highlights and IBC sections read. Restates July Imagine/Quortex closings; product launches and customer activity do not quantify retention, target cash or returns.
Reviewed Nov 3, 202625 PDF pages; pp.2–7 statements, 11–15 purchase allocations and contributions, 16 pension, 18–20 debt/tax, 21–25 shares/claims/working capital. Cash-flow p.7 visually verified.
Published Nov 4, 2026 · Reviewed Nov 4, 202617 pages; pp.4–8 revenue/organic mix and strengthening; 9–11 accounting-to-cash reconciliation; 12–17 liquidity, debt, commitments, shares and risks. FCFA2S p.11 visually verified; reported rounded values retained.
Published Nov 4, 2026 · Reviewed Nov 4, 2026Entire financial release read; 55% total revenue growth versus 3% organic, acquisition margin dilution and revised July consideration.
Published Nov 4, 2026 · Reviewed Nov 4, 2026Results, outlook and T-Mobile dispute sections. Pro-forma2027 revenue decline 7–11%, after adjusting divestitures/hardware exit; not a Lumine exposure measurement. Competitive agentic-software agreements and customer concentration warrant monitoring; the earlier 403 failure recovered.
Published Nov 3, 2026 · Reviewed Nov 8, 2026Read original operating/business highlights, continuing/discontinued operations, backlog and guidance. Reported64% continuing revenue growth is the retained broadband business after16June video disposal to MediaKind; not comparable video-software growth. Selected release sections read; full10-Q not reviewed. Web reader succeeded; direct download returned403. Older context newly checked, not a new5November disclosure.
Published Nov 2, 2026 · Reviewed Nov 5, 2026